SuperQ wrote:
> Yes, I know all about getting bit errors across the network.  TCP
> checksums and ethernet frame CRCs can be corrupted in subtle ways
> especially when your switch is doing vlan tranlations and the frame
> checksums are being recalculated.  This type of thing doesn't happen on
> home user networks so it's not really as big a deal.  We're also talking
> about very very low bandwidth rates of only a megabit or so.

I've seen it for simple TCP traffic (e.g. NFS) across a single simple IP 
router; but at likely considerably higher bandwidth, agreed.


> The point of all this is the % chance of this happening in a an audio
> stream AND not being completely obvious as garbled/static frames is so
> low it's not worth talking about.  Un-caught corruption in the
> IP/packet level will likely cause completely obvious garbled audio
> output.

agreed.

If anything, the far bigger problem comes from copying your ripped files 
across the network from one store to another, and getting (silent) 
corruption en route.

That can be avoided by using a copy mechanism incorporating its own, 
more secure, checksum/digest, e.g. SSL, SSH, encrypted NFS, etc. And of 
course this applies to all types of files.

but I'm getting a bit OT, apologies.

cheers,
calum.
_______________________________________________
audiophiles mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.slimdevices.com/mailman/listinfo/audiophiles

Reply via email to