As it says, i.e. 3.1 and later major releases.
Bob
On 13/04/2026 18:45, Independent Submissions Editor (Eliot Lear) wrote:
Hi Bob,
Thanks. First, does that "or later" cover just 3.1 or later major
releases? If the latter, can you confirm call interface
compatibility? Regardless, the references URLs need to be updated.
Eliot
On 13.04.2026 10:34, Bob Briscoe wrote:
Eliot,
Inclusive language (and the other ten rfced comments) were all fully
dealt with inside the XML that I first sent (8 Apr 26), and
highlighted in the covering email.
Since then, the rfced has deemed all but three of these eleven
conversations to have closed (incl inclusive language), so deleted
them from the XML.
The others (as listed by the RFCED, incl DOCSIS URLs) are awaiting
Greg's response on behalf of CableLabs, who is back from vac today. I
was just making sure the copyright one was added to this list for
Greg, 'cos it seemed to have been omitted. I wasn't expecting or
needing a reply.
All three URLs state "DOCSIS 3.1 Version Ixx or later", where xx in
each case was the first version of that spec to introduce LLD.
Bob
On 11/04/2026 13:01, Independent Submissions Editor (Eliot Lear) wrote:
Ok. What is left is the issue around inclusive language and the
copyright issue. Both need to be taken seriously. I will address
the inclusive language and one other issue in this message. See a
follow-up on the copyright issue.
On the use of the word "Native", because MULPI makes use of this
language, and because there is a note as to why the term is used, I
think it's okay in this instance, and would request no additional
changes.
That said, I do note two issues I would like the authors to address
at this time:
* the 3.1 links are broken in the references.
* at least some 4.0 docs (MULPI in particular) have since issued,
and they should be reviewed prior to this document's
publication. It's not like CableLabs publishes a new version
every day, and presumably they would appreciate us using their
latest, absent good cause.
I will return to the copyright issue in a separate message.
Eliot
--
________________________________________________________________
Bob Briscoehttp://bobbriscoe.net/
--
________________________________________________________________
Bob Briscoehttp://bobbriscoe.net/
--
auth48archive mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]
