Peter Kupfer OOo wrote:

I think we both agree, this is not a concept we want to push on newcomers. My thinking, as you will see below, is that as a reviewer becomes more advanced and shows signs of sticking with the project, we start introducing them to new review techniques. Kind of a teaching process.

Yes, I think we agree.

I thought about this some in the last 12 hours and I think that you don't really appreciate the difference until you are an author/maintainer and have to actually go through someone else's changes.

It's possible. But I /do/ mantain a few chapters :-) But I see your point that I've done more reviewing than maintaining so that changes my perspective.

If we don't have a formalized mentoring process, then maybe we could have a document somewhere for the "advanced members".

I have an idea:

1) On the Contributor Resources folder, add a page explaining the difference between notes and comments.

2) In the contributing page:

http://oooauthors.org/en/authors/userguide2/contribute

Add a section at the bottom titled "Tips for advanced members".

3) In it, put a link to the page on notes vs comments.

If you like this idea, I'll happily contribute another tip. I'll add the instructions on labeling images (I sent it to the list in response to a comment from Jean).

Off topic:  Check out my new sig!  :-)

Cheers,
Daniel.
--
     /\/`) Leave your mark at OpenOffice.org
    /\/_/
   /\/_/   OOoAuthors:     http://oooauthors.org
   \/_/    Knowledge Base: http://mindmeld.cybersite.com.au/
   /

Reply via email to