Berin Loritsch wrote: >>From: Nicola Ken Barozzi [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] >> >>Berin Loritsch wrote: >>... >> >>>However it is something worthy of a vote on Avalon-Dev. >> >>Present your >> >>>arguments for or against. >> >>Cocoon gives you more flexibility, but it's heavier. Have you >>tried the >>latest Cocoon I put in, it's much faster than the one you used before. > > It's been a while before I updated Cocoon. > >>On the other hand Anakia gives you speed. I personally don't >>give a damn >>about speed, since I use a validating XML editor, so I >>generate the docs >>only once a day. Have to generate the docs just to see how it >>comes out >>sucks big time. Wasn't it all about content-view separation? Then >>concentrate on the content. >> >>I prefer to have Cocoon, and I think that the current one >>works ok for >>my needs, present and future. > > > Ok. How stable is it? How easy is it to integrate with what we > have?
The avalon module has it in itself already. As for excalibur, try the Tweety doc build, and look in that to see how it's done-reused. >>A suggestion: in Centipede, I can use Maven's Anakia to generate the >>documentation. In this way Cocoon is used for the real site, Maven's >>Anakia for the ones that want speed in the doc writing cycle >>and don't >>use validating parsers. >> >>On the top of this, Forrest uses Cocoon and we're getting ready to >>support builds of Apache sites. The Forrest site is >>autogenerated every >>hour and published automatically to http://www.krysalis.org/forrest/ . >> >>I really hope we will use Forrest. > > > > I honestly care primarily about the end result at this point. All I > know > is that some Avalon projects are using one thing, and supposedly other > projects are using something else. I don't recall seeing anything > official > for direction in this area beyond when I first introduced Cocoon. And IIRC there was consensus for Cocoon, but I may be wrong. I think that Peter uses Anakia because he wasn't able to use supplied Cocoon, and that it's a temporary thing. > I don't want the build environment confused anymore than necessary. > > Is the report true? Do we have some Avalon projects using Anakia and > others > using Cocoon? If so stop it, and lets vote on the subject. If it is > true, > I -1 the action, vetoeing it until we come up with a solution. > > We need one doc building solution. I brought this up when you were away and IIRC Peter needed an interim solution to continue working. AFAIK we're reverting to Cocoon now. -- Nicola Ken Barozzi [EMAIL PROTECTED] - verba volant, scripta manent - (discussions get forgotten, just code remains) --------------------------------------------------------------------- -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> For additional commands, e-mail: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
