Sorry for the reticence today, Tom and I have been mired in debugging all day. :(
I would prefer that we not move too far towards having all the samples + tests be based on generation from WSDL. When we originally changed the code of the echo sample to be generated and then checked in, I was OK with that, but I think I'd rather it stay that way than be generated. So I'm -0. Also, echoMap is implemented by several other vendors and should definitely stay in there, IMHO. Keeping them in there keeps the interop results up to date and tests good functionality. --Glen > -----Original Message----- > From: R J Scheuerle Jr [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] > Sent: Friday, April 05, 2002 3:36 PM > To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > Cc: Sam Ruby > Subject: Proposal to change EchoTest (interop test) to be gen'd from > wsdl > > > The samples.echo service and artifacts are hand-crafted and > committed code. > Thus the stubs and artifacts are frequently out of date with > the emitters > and runtime. > > I propose changing the sample so that the service, stubs and beans are > generated > directly from the WSDL supplied by WhiteMesa (actually local > copies of the > WSDLs with > our service stanzas added). > > I am implementing these changes in my sandbox, and I have > come across 2 > "problems": > > 1) The TestClient has two options which affect the setting of the > soapAction. The > emitted stub is hard-coded to use the soapAction specified in > the wsdl (a > good thing). > So I propose eliminating these two options from > TestClient...they are not > used in our > scripts anyway. > > 2) The current code has echoMap and echoMapArray operations. > Neither of > these > are present in the white mesa wsdl document (and almost all > of the remote > services > fail to implement these operations). I propose getting rid of these > operations. If someone > thinks they are useful, we should move them to another test. > > Any comments ? > > Could I get some +1's. Thanks, > > Rich Scheuerle > XML & Web Services Development > 512-838-5115 (IBM TL 678-5115) >
