karl,
>>> nir: > As in my response to rolf, at issue is historical and contextual > consideration about changes in etymology. > In fact, most lexicographers give several options for a word, > which may be quite Mutually Incompatible. > >>> karl: Why only in Biblical Hebrew? I don’t find that in other languages. a list of different meanings is indeed the practice in every serious dictionary in every language, old or new. otherwise the exact meaning of the word is missed by an over-simplified "single meaning" of the type produced by your type of analysis. you may start with the merriam webster english dictionary. the definition of the word "call" there takes a couple of pages, of which i quote below only the initial part. at the end they also give the historical linguistic evolution of the word in languages of the same group. nir cohen --------------------------------------- Definition of CALL intransitive verb 1 a : to speak in a loud distinct voice so as to be heard at a distance : shout <call for help> b : to make a request or demand <call for an investigation> c of an animal : to utter a characteristic note or cry d : to get or try to get into communication by telephone <just called to say hello> —often used with up e : to make a demand in card games (as for a particular card or for a show of hands) f : to give the calls for a square dance 2: to make a brief visit <called to pay his respects> <called on a friend> transitive verb 1a (1) : to utter in a loud distinct voice —often used with out <call out a number> (2) : to announce or read loudly or authoritatively <call the roll> <call off a row of figures> (3) : to announce the play-by-play of (as a football game) b (1) : to command or request to come or be present <was called to testify> (2) : to cause to come : bring <calls to mind an old saying> c : to summon to a particular activity, employment, or office <was called to active duty> <was called to the bar of justice> d : to invite or command to meet : convoke <call a meeting> e : to rouse from sleep or summon to get up f (1) : to give the order for : bring into action <call a strike against the company> <call a pitchout> (2) : to manage by giving the signals or orders <that catcher calls a good game> g (1) : to make a demand in bridge for (a card or suit) (2) : to require (a player) to show the hand in poker by making an equal bet (3) : to challenge to make good on a statement (4) : to charge with or censure for an offense <deserves to be called on that> h : to attract (as game) by imitating the characteristic cry i : to halt (as a baseball game) because of unsuitable conditions j : to rule on the status of (as a pitched ball or a player's action) <call balls and strikes> <call a base runner safe> k : to give the calls for (a square dance) —often used with off l (1) : to demand payment of especially by formal notice <call a loan> (2) : to demand presentation of (as a bond or option) for redemption m (1) : to get or try to get in communication with by telephone <call the doctor to make an appointment> (2) : to generate signals for (a telephone number) in order to reach the party to whom the number is assigned <call 911> (3) : to make a signal to in order to transmit a message <call the flagship> 2a : to speak of or address by a specified name : give a name to <call her Kitty> b (1) : to regard or characterize as of a certain kind : consider <can hardly be called generous> ( 2) : to estimate or consider for purposes of an estimate or for convenience <call it an even dollar> c (1) : to describe correctly in advance of or without knowledge of the event : predict (2) : to name or specify in advance <call the toss of a coin> 3: to temporarily transfer control of computer processing to (as a subroutine or procedure) — call a spade a spade 1: to call a thing by its right name however coarse 2: to speak frankly — call for 1: to call (as at one's house) to get <I'll call for you after dinner> 2: to require as necessary or appropriate <the job calls for typing skills> <the design calls for three windows> etc etc etc *** then it brings a HISTORICAL SURVEY OF THE WORD: Origin of CALL Middle English, from Old Norse kalla; akin to Old English hildecalla battle herald, Old High German kallōn to talk loudly, Old Church Slavic glasŭ voice First Known Use: before 12th century _______________________________________________ b-hebrew mailing list [email protected] http://lists.ibiblio.org/mailman/listinfo/b-hebrew
