On 06/01/2008, David Matthews <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Dave Crossland wrote: > > On 06/01/2008, David Matthews <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > >> Well it's not that hard to get iPlayer content on the Xbox. Once Linux > >> (e.g. Xebian) is installed then essentially the Xbox is just another > >> Linux x86 machine. Install IceWeasel/Firefox and the Flash plugin and > >> iPlayer works fine. > > > > This would be unethical (since the Adobe flash plugin in not shareable > > or modifiable) and it breaks the Flash EULA section 3.1. > > Unethical in what way? There's a question about whether this complies > with EULA section 3.1 but I would maintain that an Xbox running Linux is > a PC and not a games console especially when all the games-related stuff > has been removed. I wasn't suggesting porting anything to the original > XBox operating system or modifying the plugin in any way, merely > pointing out that it was possible to run iPlayer on the Xbox hardware.
Its technically possible, but it breaks the EULA contract, and if this contract is valid, it is illegal. But, it might not be legally binding, and in that case you just break an agreement, which isn't a big deal, but it is slightly unethical to backstab like that. Section 3.1 says: "For the avoidance of doubt, and by example only, you may not use a Web Player on any (a) mobile devices, set top boxes (STB), handhelds, phones, web pads, tablets and Tablet PCs that are not running Windows XP Tablet PC Edition, game consoles," The Xbox hardware is sold as a game console and your modification to its software does not change that. Supposing that it does, you now have a computer with its primary display being a television, which makes it a "set top box." Either way, you would agree not to use the Adobe Flash player in this way if you used it, and to break an agreement is obviously not ethical. Using any propriety software is not ethical though, because you give up your own freedom to use, study, share and improve the software. Where this effects other people, it is unethical; mainly, if you cannot share it with a friend, you betray your friends; also, you suggest to them that they ought to give up their freedom, which is a kind of indirect ethical pollution. > Certainly an open source solution that avoids these uncertainties is a > better answer. For sure! Thanks for taking time to discuss this with me, -- Regards, Dave (Personal opinion only!) - Sent via the backstage.bbc.co.uk discussion group. To unsubscribe, please visit http://backstage.bbc.co.uk/archives/2005/01/mailing_list.html. Unofficial list archive: http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/

