j903 accepts -- but j904 rejects -- this way of defining rational infinity:

_r1

|ill-formed number

| _r1

| ^

JVERSION

Engine: j904/j64arm/darwin

Beta-k: commercial/2023-01-24T04:42:28

Library: 9.04.10

Qt IDE: 2.0.3/6.2.4(6.2.4)

Platform: Darwin 64

Installer: J904 install

InstallPath: /applications/j904

Contact: www.jsoftware.com

A workaround is to use 1r0 instead:


1r0

_

datatype 1r0

rational


Not a lot of j-ers willl have a use for rational [minus] infinity, but IMO
a beginner might find it more intuitive to define it as _r1 rather than 1r0
. Maybe it's no big deal in itself, but it breaks 3 addons, viz: math/cal,
math/uu -- and in consequence math/tabula:


   load'math/uu' NB. Launch UU only
|ill-formed number in script, executing monad 0!: 0
|any word beginning with a digit or _ must be a valid number
|   BADRAT=: __r1
|            ^
|[-33] /applications/j904/addons/math/uu/uu.ijs

   load'math/cal'
|ill-formed number in script, executing monad 0!: 0
|any word beginning with a digit or _ must be a valid number
|   BAD_EXE_VALUE=: __r1
|                   ^
|[-92] /applications/j904/addons/math/cal/cal.ijs


So I'd call it a bug.


There's been plenty of time to discover this. Sorry it's taken me so long.


Ian Clark
----------------------------------------------------------------------
For information about J forums see http://www.jsoftware.com/forums.htm

Reply via email to