fwiw, I am a strong -1 on officially supporting any platform that we don't have automated tests running against, and given the install base for CentOS/RHEL 5 out there, I'm -1 on excluding CentOS 5 from the supported list.
A. On Fri, Sep 9, 2011 at 10:21 PM, Bruno Mahé <[email protected]> wrote: > On 09/06/2011 04:43 PM, Bruno Mahé wrote: > > On 09/06/2011 01:44 PM, Bruno Mahé wrote: > >> Hi, > >> > >> Given no one has objected to the previous thread, I am calling a vote. > >> > >> So let's vote on adopting the following set of platforms: > >> * Latest released CentOS (currently 6.0) > >> * Latest released Ubuntu LTS (currently 10.04) > >> * Latest released OpenSUSE (currently 11.4) > >> * Latest released Fedora (currently 15) > >> > >> This means we can't check in any patch that will break any of these > OSes. > >> It also means we can't upgrade a component of BigTop if that component > >> cannot be built or tested on all of these OSes. > >> > >> > >> This does not preclude anyone to add support for or maintain any other > >> platform, but this would not be a requirement for BigTop. > >> > >> > >> The vote is open for 72 hours, and is open to anyone on the committers > >> or mentors list at http://incubator.apache.org/projects/bigtop.html. > >> > >> > >> Thanks! > >> > > > > Since I want to focus on the list of supported platforms I am replacing: > > "This means we can't check in any patch that will break any of these > > OSes. It also means we can't upgrade a component of BigTop if that > > component cannot be built or tested on all of these OSes. " > > by > > "This means we can't release any version of BigTop with broken support > > for any of these OSes (including build and tests). It also means we > > can't upgrade a component of BigTop if that component cannot be built or > > tested on all of these OSes. " > > The vote has passed with 5 +1s and either 1 or 2 -1s (depending on how > Andrew Bayer's last vote is interpreted). > > +1 Andre Arcilla > +1 Edward J. Yoon > +1 Peter Linnell > +1 Roman Shaposhnik > +1 Myself > > -1 Steve Loughran > > Andrew Bayer is either +0 or -1. It was not clear but either choice > would not change the result. > > Thank you all for voting, and ensuring a bright future for BigTop! >
