"Fighting" sprawl from a sprawlburb. > >Eco-Friendly Is in Eye of Beholder > >Wildlife Group's Headquarters Criticized for Suburban Sprawl > > > >By Peter Whoriskey > >Washington Post Staff Writer > >Wednesday, March 21, 2001; Page B01 > > > > > >The new National Wildlife Federation headquarters in Reston is, in the > >group's own assessment, a model of environmental design. > > > >Ponds lined with cattails will purify rainwater running off the parking > >lot. A three-story trellis on the sunny, south facade is intended to keep > >the building shaded in summer. The wood used for the front desk was > >harvested from ecologically managed forests. > > > >"It's as environmentally benign a building as you can develop within a > >reasonable budget," federation President Mark Van Putten said of the > $17.4 > >million project, which will be dedicated next month. > > > >But for a national organization leading a "Smart Growth & Wildlife" > >campaign against suburban sprawl and the threat it poses to species as > >diverse as the Florida panther, the black-tailed prairie dog and the > >Pacific salmon, the new headquarters stands as a curious monument: > > > >It looks a lot like sprawl. > > > >Located at the end of a winding road that runs through a suburban office > >park just off the Dulles Toll Road, the new three-story building is > fronted > >by a parking lot for 285 cars -- much like its neighbors -- in a > >conventional low-density landscape of modern office buildings scattered > in > >an expanse of striped asphalt and berms. > > > >So while federation leaders describe their new headquarters as a > statement > >of environmental responsibility, others see it as a symptom of the growth > >phenomenon, not its cure. > > > >"This is a sprawl area, and this building continues the pattern," said > >Warren Boeschenstein, an architecture professor at the University of > >Virginia. "While an area like this can evolve into something more, a > >building with a large parking lot in front is not likely to lead that > >evolution." > > > >"Another office building isolated in another office campus is not smart > >growth, it's sprawl," said Stewart Schwartz, director of the Coalition > for > >Smarter Growth and one of the leading anti-sprawl advocates in the > >Washington area. "Most environmental groups locate in downtown areas, on > >purpose, to live the message, to literally walk the walk." > > > >That one of the nation's leading conservation groups finds itself being > >accused of questionable development decisions underscores the difficulty > of > >achieving pure smart growth within a limited budget and the complexity of > >the growing debate over sprawl. > > > >"The development decisions the National Wildlife Federation was faced > with > >were probably the same ones that face any office developer," said Ned > >Farquhar, a member of the steering committee of Smart Growth America, a > >coalition of environmental, planning and historic preservation groups. > >"Unfortunately, the economics favor building sprawl. It's cheaper." > > > >One of the nation's leading environmental groups, the National Wildlife > >Federation boasts more than 4 million supporters. Its old headquarters, > on > >Route 7 near Wolf Trap Farm Park, was deemed too big and soldto a McLean > >church group in 1999. In constructing the new Reston headquarters, > leaders > >said they wanted to build in a manner that was both environmentally and > >fiscally prudent. > > > >"We have a responsibility to our members and donors to make every dollar > >count," Van Putten said. "We are the common-sense conservation group." > > > >The group purchased the Reston parcel for $3.9 million in April 1999. The > >federation did consider other, more urban locations that probably would > >have pleased its critics, but those sites, near the Clarendon and > Ballston > >Metro stops, cost too much, among other things, Van Putten said. Another > >anti-sprawl feature -- building a multitiered parking garage rather than > a > >parking lot -- was also deemed too expensive. > > > >Some leading environmental groups say that by locating in cities or > >designated growth areas, they underscore the conservation message. > > > >The National Audubon Society moved its national headquarters to a > >refurbished building in Manhattan in 1992. Five years ago, the Sierra > Club > >moved into remodeled space in downtown San Francisco, one block from a > Bay > >Area Rapid Transit stop. And the Chesapeake Bay Foundation recently > located > >its headquarters south of Annapolis, in one of Maryland's designated > >smart-growth areas, although its new site is about a mile from the > nearest > >bus stop. > > > >Environmentalists believe that suburban sprawl threatens wildlife in two > >key ways. > > > >First, because it's spread out, it consumes more land than downtown > >development does. Second, it generates air and water pollution by > >encouraging automobile dependence. Doing errands in the suburbs -- where > >offices, shops and homes are typically distanced from one another -- > >usually requires getting in a car. > > > >A report last year by the Chesapeake Bay Foundation underscored the > impact > >of sprawl in the Washington area. Development is consuming land more than > >twice as fast as the population is growing, the report found; and, for > >related reasons, the number of miles traveled by car is climbing faster > >than the population, too. > > > >Like other environmental groups, the Wildlife Federation considers > >containing sprawl a key to conservation. > > > >"In a recent study of why species are listed as threatened or endangered > . > >. . researchers found that urbanization endangers more listed U.S. > species > >than any other cause," according to the federation's Web site, > www.nwf.org. > > > >The alternative to sprawl, many planners say, is so-called smart growth: > >compact traditional downtowns that combine homes, offices and shops and > >provide convenient bus or rail service. Think of Ballston in Arlington > >County. > > > >Does the Wildlife Federation's new headquarters measure up? > > > >Its location in a suburban office park is in many ways the antithesis of > a > >pedestrian-friendly, land-conserving downtown. On the other hand, a > string > >of fast-food outlets lies within walking distance and gives employees the > >option of having lunch away from their desks. > > > >Currently, the office park has infrequent bus service, though a Metro > >station is planned for a site about three-quarters-of-a-mile walk away. > >That's farther than most smart-growth guidelines call for -- the > >federation's own Web site suggests that new offices should be > "immediately > >adjacent" to transit stations -- but federation officials say their > >conservation-minded employees are more likely than others to go the extra > >distance for transit. > > > >Finally, while the headquarters was built on seven acres of vacant land > -- > >requiring the removal of dozens of Virginia pines, tulip poplars, red > >maples and other trees, according to plans filed with the county -- the > >property was not a pristine location on the fringe of the metropolitan > >area. Indeed, the site was already surrounded by, and planned for, > >development. > > > >"Going out farther to Loudoun or Prince William counties may have been > >sprawl," Van Putten said. "But this site was within Reston, an existing > >planned community." > > > >Moreover, Van Putten said, other factors make the Reston site a good > >choice. > > > >The property backs up to a park, which he said will remind staff of the > >federation's conservation mission. Because the Washington & Old Dominion > >bike trail passes right by, the group intends to purchase a fleet of > bikes > >for employee use. Other features make the building energy-efficient and > >lessen its impact on the environment. > > > >In the final analysis, federation leaders said, the Reston site made > sense > >because most of the staff -- 181 of 249 employees -- live in Virginia, > the > >majority of them drive to work and many live close to the new > headquarters. > > > >"It is in a suburban office park, and there is no way of getting around > >that," said John Kostyack, who heads the federation's smart-growth > >campaign. "But you want to have people living near where they work, and > >when I look at it that way, the site makes a great deal of sense. > > > >"Sprawl is not a black-and-white issue. Sure, a case can be made that > >building in a downtown looks more like smart growth, but that's not a > good > >analysis. There are complex factors that come into play." > > > > > > > >© 2001 The Washington Post Company >
