A response to those hysterical road builders' scary scenario ads. It looks from the post as though it's from the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, although I couldn't find it on their website's summary of editorials, and it doesn't read like something from a mainstream newspaper anyway. But fun to read anyway. > >Constitution: Disregard road builders' propaganda > >Staff > >Wednesday, March 21, 2001 > > > >Viewed as something of a sick joke, those television ads by the Georgia > >Highway Contractors Association are hysterical. > > > >The road builders are mad because Atlanta's long-standing refusal to get > a > >handle on its automobile-related air pollution has caused a lengthy delay > >in road funding, and they have made themselves dependent on that > government > >teat. But do they blame state or local governments, the automobile > >industry, developers or --- heaven forbid --- themselves for the > pollution > >problem and myriad other spin-off effects of the region's abysmally > managed > >growth? > > > >Nah. They blame the pesky environmentalists, who are insisting that the > >state comply with national laws aimed at protecting the environment for > >everyone --- even the highway builders and their families. > >Environmentalists have the temerity to argue that the right to clean air > >and water is as important as the right to live in your car, if you so > >choose. > > > >Employing a level of subtlety and sophistication last seen in 1950s > Soviet > >propaganda, the road builders are airing a pair of TV ads claiming those > >evil bunny-lovers are "preventing us from driving cars and forcing us to > >live downtown." > > > >Oh, you laugh, but any day now the eco-Gestapo will show up at your > >cul-de-sac, demand the keys to your house and car, stuff you into a bus > and > >deliver you to your new coat closet on the 15th floor of the Equitable > >building. > > > >The imagery they choose is priceless, too. One opens with a Technicolor > >scene of a white mom unloading groceries from her minivan as her son > plays, > >dressed for soccer. "Don't let Atlanta's environmental activists take > away > >your right to live where you want and drive when you want," the voice > >intones. "They're trying to use laws and lawsuits to move families out of > >the suburbs and into downtown." The ad switches from color to black and > >white as an image of downtown, clearly meant to be frightening, appears, > >followed by a shot of black people getting off a bus. (Get it? In your > car, > >you're safe from the scary black people.) > > > >Really, how stupid do they think we are? Plenty, obviously. So stupid > that > >we believe more of the same --- more roads with more lanes, more strip > >centers and shopping malls, more parking lots, more long commutes --- > will > >magically cure our pollution and congestion problems. > > > >Or maybe they don't really care about such a cure. Maybe it's not about > our > >freedoms and our rights. Maybe it's just about more profits. > > > >It's not as though road-building is gone for good, in any event. True, > the > >region's long-range transportation plan no longer assumes that absolutely > >every dollar will go to highway contractors. But the plan has hundreds of > >miles of new and widened roads in it, in addition to the transit > projects. > >And it is the road portion of the budget that has guaranteed funding; the > >transit money is far from certain. > > > >The truly funny thing is that the contractors' assault on so-called smart > >growth, which seeks to make the most use of already-developed areas, > could > >very well prove self-defeating. Smart growth attempts to be a reasonable > >alternative to no growth, a sentiment that is swelling in metro Atlanta. > A > >lot of Atlantans have decided they've given over as much of their > >neighborhoods to new roads and development as they care to. > > > >If it's sprawl or nothing, many folks would just as soon take nothing. > > > > > ON THE WEB: To view these ads: www.ajc.com > >
