Bill, if I told you 2 plus 2 actually equals 5, would you print that? I
suppose you might, knowing that everyone who reads would catch the error.
But what if I told you that the circumference of a circle is pie times
the radius of the circle cubed? Would you also print that, without
explanation or correction?
And what if I told you the slavery was in the African American's best
interest, for 400 years, and that African Americans today are
unquestionably better off now, than they would have otherwise been?
Would you also print that, without explanation? I realize some
newspapers would do that, as did the Badger Herald, but I would not have
thought Isthmus would have, but now I'm not so sure anymore. I consider
media helping to broadcast clearly erroneous information to be
irresponsible, especially when it hurts people or society in general, as
both these issues do.
Mike Neuman
4334 Waite Circle
Madison, WI
(608) 238-6866
Feel free to put (and edit as necessary) either of my last two messages
in your newspaper, at your discretion of course.
Mike
On Fri, 23 Mar 2001 09:29:24 -0600 "Bill Lueders" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
writes:
>Actually, Mike, I agree with you, in part. I think Cockburn is on very
>thin
>ice here. I found his column objectionable, even as I gave it the
>benefit of
>my expert editing. I'm not certain he's wrong, but I frankly have more
>trust
>in the overwhelming majority of the world's climatologists than in the
>lone
>expert he trots out. Here's where I disagree with you: First of all,
>the
>offering was not an article, as you say. It was a clearly labeled
>Opinion
>column. Second, I disagree that it was irresponsible to run. Part of
>a
>newspaper's job is to present points of view with which its editors do
>not
>agree. That's what happens virtually every time we run an offering
>from
>Charlie Sykes, another regular columnist, and it's true for a good
>deal of
>our letters to the editor. Speaking of which, instead of responding
>to
>Cockburn's column with a note to all and sundry accusing Isthmus of
>being
>irresponsible for not silencing points of view with which you
>disagree, you
>could always write us a letter to the editor, in response to what Alex
>had
>to say. If you decide to go this route, we do need your address and
>phone
>number (not to publish), per our letters policy.
>
>
>-----Original Message-----
>From: Michael Neuman [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]
>Sent: Friday, March 23, 2001 6:55 AM
>To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
>Cc: [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED];
>[EMAIL PROTECTED];
>[EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED];
>[EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED];
>[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>Subject: Isthmus Newspaper Article Irresponsible
>
>
>Unless it has been purposefully written to stir up very much needed
>controversy (locally anyway), I believe Isthmus' decision to publish
>Alexander Cockburn's column this week, questioning the accuracy of
>current global warming research, is an example of irresponsible
>journalism.
>
>Colburn's opinion column concludes with this quote from former
>governmental analyst Pierre (who pays his salary?) Sprey: "The
>greenhouse gas thesis is most emphatically nonproven."
>
>This above sentence is a falsehood, as reported in the two other
>local
>Madison newspapers last week ["Greenhouse Gas Buildup Real: Experts",
>CTs, 3/14/01; "Research Proves the Existence of Greenhouse Gases",
>WSJ,
>3/15/01].
>
>Don't you folks at Isthmus read other newspapers other than your own?
>
>This downplaying of the reality of global warming and its predicted
>disastrous impacts to Earth and all its living resources is dangerous
>to
>our society, and therefore our community. The mantras of corporate
>propaganda, which encourage us all to overconsume, travel at will,
>and
>use electricity for things we can physically do ourselves, are
>broadcast
>over all forms of media, endlessly. They successfully convince most
>of
>us that we can all continue to, as environmental economist Kenneth
>Boulding once said, "eat, drink, spend, extract, and pollute, and be
>as
>merry as we can, and let posterity worry about the spaceship earth".
>
>Boulding was disturbed by this line of thinking 35 years ago, when he
>wrote his article on the requirements of living a spaceship earth:
>
>"There has always been something rather refreshing in the view that
>we
>should live like the birds, and perhaps posterity is for the birds in
>more senses than one; so perhaps we should all call it a day and go
>out
>and pollute something cheerfully. As an old taker of thought for the
>morrow, however, I cannot quite accept this solution; and I would
>argue,
>furthermore, that tomorrow is not only very close, but in many
>respects,
>it is already here. THE SHADOW OF THE FUTURE SPACESHIP, INDEED, IS
>ALREADY FALLING OVER OUR SPENDTHRIFT MERRIMENT. Oddly enough, it
>seems
>to be in pollution rather than exhaustion that the problem is first
>becoming salient." [From: "The Economics of the Coming Spaceship
>Earth",
>by Kenneth E. Boulding, from Henry Jarrett, ed., Environmental Quality
>in
>a Growing Economy (1966), published by Resources for the Future, Inc.
>1970]
>
>We all should be disturb about this. Cockburn's article attempts to
>make
>us all feel good about our over consumption and pollution of the
>earth's
>resources. I feel worse for having read it. Your newspaper promotes
>the
>agenda of the fossil fuel and transportation industries by publishing
>irresponsible opinion that encourage us all to continue to fill up
>the
>pockets of the fossil fuel dependent industries with green when our
>entire planet is beginning to turn brown.
>
>
>________________________________________________________________
>GET INTERNET ACCESS FROM JUNO!
>Juno offers FREE or PREMIUM Internet access for less!
>Join Juno today! For your FREE software, visit:
>http://dl.www.juno.com/get/tagj.
>
________________________________________________________________
GET INTERNET ACCESS FROM JUNO!
Juno offers FREE or PREMIUM Internet access for less!
Join Juno today! For your FREE software, visit:
http://dl.www.juno.com/get/tagj.