Agreed. Cockburn's rants have tended to be a little stranger than normal
lately, in light of his leftist posturings. Look out, Horowitz, here
comes the competition.
On Fri, 23 Mar 2001 10:25:39 -0600 Chris Deisinger <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
writes:
> Let's be clear. It is not irresponsible for Isthmus to run a
> particular
> column by Alexander Cockburn or anyone else. Newspapers customarily
> have
> relationships with columnists who are then given the latitude, not
> subject
> to piece by piece censorship (unless there are issues of libel,
> etc.), to
> express their opinions on a regular basis, even ones that are
> provocative
> or that are at variance with the prevailing attitudes of readers or
> of the
> editorial stance of the paper itself.. Having said that, I do think
> that
> Isthmus should reexamine the worth of running columns by Cockburn at
> all.
> Isthmus already runs a column by Charlie Sykes - a conservative who
> regularly defends Republicans, attacks Democrats and criticizes
> environmentalists. Cockburn does all these things as well while
> posing as
> someone on the left. While I don't agree with much of Sykes'
> viewpoint, he
> has some integrity and exhibits a need to make his arguments
> credible.
> Cockburn has no compunction about attacking his favorite targets
> (all on
> the left) with slander, exaggeration and half-assed logic. He is the
> Trotskyist Rush Limbaugh. Isthmus and its readers would be better
> served by
> providing a column by an actual progressive.
>
>
>
> At 06:54 AM 3/23/2001 -0600, Michael Neuman wrote:
> >Unless it has been purposefully written to stir up very much needed
> >controversy (locally anyway), I believe Isthmus' decision to
> publish
> >Alexander Cockburn's column this week, questioning the accuracy of
> >current global warming research, is an example of irresponsible
> >journalism.
> >
> >Colburn's opinion column concludes with this quote from former
> >governmental analyst Pierre (who pays his salary?) Sprey: "The
> >greenhouse gas thesis is most emphatically nonproven."
> >
> >This above sentence is a falsehood, as reported in the two other
> local
> >Madison newspapers last week ["Greenhouse Gas Buildup Real:
> Experts",
> >CTs, 3/14/01; "Research Proves the Existence of Greenhouse Gases",
> WSJ,
> >3/15/01].
> >
> >Don't you folks at Isthmus read other newspapers other than your
> own?
> >
> >This downplaying of the reality of global warming and its predicted
> >disastrous impacts to Earth and all its living resources is
> dangerous to
> >our society, and therefore our community. The mantras of corporate
> >propaganda, which encourage us all to overconsume, travel at will,
> and
> >use electricity for things we can physically do ourselves, are
> broadcast
> >over all forms of media, endlessly. They successfully convince
> most of
> >us that we can all continue to, as environmental economist Kenneth
> >Boulding once said, "eat, drink, spend, extract, and pollute, and
> be as
> >merry as we can, and let posterity worry about the spaceship
> earth".
> >
> >Boulding was disturbed by this line of thinking 35 years ago, when
> he
> >wrote his article on the requirements of living a spaceship earth:
> >
> >"There has always been something rather refreshing in the view that
> we
> >should live like the birds, and perhaps posterity is for the birds
> in
> >more senses than one; so perhaps we should all call it a day and go
> out
> >and pollute something cheerfully. As an old taker of thought for
> the
> >morrow, however, I cannot quite accept this solution; and I would
> argue,
> >furthermore, that tomorrow is not only very close, but in many
> respects,
> >it is already here. THE SHADOW OF THE FUTURE SPACESHIP, INDEED, IS
> >ALREADY FALLING OVER OUR SPENDTHRIFT MERRIMENT. Oddly enough, it
> seems
> >to be in pollution rather than exhaustion that the problem is first
> >becoming salient." [From: "The Economics of the Coming Spaceship
> Earth",
> >by Kenneth E. Boulding, from Henry Jarrett, ed., Environmental
> Quality in
> >a Growing Economy (1966), published by Resources for the Future,
> Inc.
> >1970]
> >
> >We all should be disturb about this. Cockburn's article attempts
> to make
> >us all feel good about our over consumption and pollution of the
> earth's
> >resources. I feel worse for having read it. Your newspaper
> promotes the
> >agenda of the fossil fuel and transportation industries by
> publishing
> >irresponsible opinion that encourage us all to continue to fill up
> the
> >pockets of the fossil fuel dependent industries with green when our
> >entire planet is beginning to turn brown.
> >
> >
> >________________________________________________________________
> >GET INTERNET ACCESS FROM JUNO!
> >Juno offers FREE or PREMIUM Internet access for less!
> >Join Juno today! For your FREE software, visit:
> >http://dl.www.juno.com/get/tagj.
> >
>
>
>
> ____________________
>
> Chris Deisinger
> MSB Energy Associates
> Suite 200
> 7507 Hubbard Avenue
> Middleton, WI., 53562
> Phone: (608) 831-1127 Ext. 309
> Fax: (608) 836-1290
>
> http://www.msbnrg.com
>
>