Note: This email is an opinion and not an attack on bitcoin

Covenants on bitcoin will eventually be implemented with a soft fork. CTV is 
the easiest and best possible way OP_TX looks good as well. Apart from the 
technical merits, covenants will improve a few other things:

- Developers can build interesting projects with real demand in market.
- Students learn Sapio and not just solidity.
- Better tooling could be available for application developers.
- Maybe we see bitcoin developer hackathons in different countries.
- Demand for block space might increase, it wont be just exchanges and coinjoin.
- Funding of bitcoin developers and projects might improve. Wont need to 
convince a few people for grants.

**Why covenants are not contentious?**

Some people may write paragraphs about CTV being contentious, spread 
misinformation and do all types of drama, politics etc. on social media but 
there are zero technical NACKs for CTV. We have discussed other covenant 
proposals in detail on mailing list and IRC meetings with an open minded 
approach.

All the developers that participated in the discussion are either okay with CTV 
or OP_TX or covenants in general.

**How and when should covenants be implemented in Bitcoin?**

I don't think we should wait for years anticipating a proposal that everyone 
will agree on or argue for years to pretend changes are hard in Bitcoin. We 
should improve the review process for soft fork BIPs and share honest opinions 
with agreement, disagreement on technical merits.

I prefer BIP 8 or improved BIP 8 for soft fork but I won't mind anything else 
being used if that improves Bitcoin. Covenants implemented in Bitcoin before 
the next cycle would provide opportunity for developers to build interesting 
things during the bear market. Ossification supporters also believe there is 
some window that will close soon, maybe doing changes considering each case 
individually will be a better approach. CTV is not a rushed soft fork, less 
people followed the research and it was not mentioned on social media 
repeatedly by the respected developers like other soft forks.

/dev/fd0


Sent with Proton Mail secure email.
_______________________________________________
bitcoin-dev mailing list
bitcoin-dev@lists.linuxfoundation.org
https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/bitcoin-dev

Reply via email to