On 04/03/2016 22:43, Fernando de Oliveira wrote: > Em 04-03-2016 18:09, Bruce Dubbs escreveu: >> Pierre Labastie wrote: >>> On 04/03/2016 17:16, Ken Moffat wrote: >>>> On Fri, Mar 04, 2016 at 12:10:46PM -0300, Fernando de Oliveira wrote: >>>>> Em 04-03-2016 09:08, Pierre Labastie escreveu: >>>> (trimming severely) >>>>>> On 04/03/2016 11:36, Fernando de Oliveira wrote: >>>>>>> Em 04-03-2016 06:15, Pierre Labastie escreveu: >>>>>>>> Does somebody know which kf5 and >>>>>>>> plasma deps are really needed? >>>>>> Anyway, I'll build all of plasma because I am in a hurry to tag lxqt, >>>>>> and I do not have time to search which lib needs which dep. >>>>> Perhaps I am understanding now. >>>>> >>>>> When the LXQt instructions where written, they worked for what we >>>>> had in >>>>> Plasma and KF5. Now, Plasma and KF5 changed and consequently the LXQt >>>>> instructions have to change in order to sync? >>>>> >>>>> When I did the pages, everything was there. >>>>> >>>>> Now, someone, perhaps you(?) needs to do it again. I never liked LXQt, >>>>> because the the devs are KDE devs, each new version, new "KDE" >>>>> dependencies are always introduced. >>>>> >>>>> something else was modified, now the dependency chain is modified. >>>>> >>>>> I cannot fix. >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> However, the list of dependencies are at: >>>>> >>>>> https://github.com/lxde/lxqt/wiki/Building-From-Source >>>>> >>>>> and do not seem to have been modified. >>>>> >>>> The last time I built lxqt, the only KF5 deps it needed were: >>>> >>>> extra-cmake-modules >>>> >>>> kwindowsystem (I built those two before liblxqt) >>>> >>>> kguiaddons (I built that before libstatgrab) >>>> >>>> I can see that I also built oxygen-icons from kde4, and the qt5 >>>> version of polkit-qt. >>>> >>>> From what I remember, it really required openbox (I had thought >>>> other 'box WMs might pass muster). >>>> >>>> ĸen >>> Thanks, >>> >>> Actually, as I said, I built all of kf5 and plasma. I found a small (but >>> annoying, because libksysguard was not applied the fix) bug in the plasma >>> instructions, (see commit r17061), so hopefully, making the book better. >>> >>> Otherwise, the LXQT build went smoothly, so I think the instructions are >>> good. I have built openbox, lxdm and sddm. I still have to test that now. >>> >>> To Fernando, I understood you hadn't understood my first post. That's why >>> I explained. I'm glad we agree (I do not like LXQt either, for the same >>> reasons as you...). >> >> I've read the thread. I have to admit that I haven't built LXQt. >> Looking through the instructions, I don't really like the way the >> kf5/plasma dependencies are presented. >> >> From what I can see, the following are needed: >> >> From KF5: kwindowsystem, kguiaddons, solid >> Form Plasma: libkscreen >> >> These in turn have dependencies. Looking at the CMakeLists.txt files in >> those packages tells me that they need extra-cmake-modules and the xcb >> libraries in xorg. libkscreen has an optional dependency of doxygen. >> >> Solid has optional dependencies media-player-info (not in the book), >> udisks2, and upower. >> >> >> My preference would be to add pages for kwindowsystem, kguiaddons, >> solid, and libkscreen to the book in the LXQt section and add a note >> that they are also built as a part of KF5 and (or plasma for libkscreen) >> and do not need to be rebuilt if those multiple package installs have >> been made. >> >> If needed I can test it by just renaming /opt/kf5. (Another good reason >> for building in /opt). > > Second time you propose. > > Please, make it readable. I always fail. > > Thanks. >
I realize I should have read again the thread starting at http://lists.linuxfromscratch.org/pipermail/blfs-dev/2015-November/031384.html. Sorry for duplicate. I think we should create a ticket and discuss there what to do (after release). I'll do that unless somebody speaks up Pierre -- http://lists.linuxfromscratch.org/listinfo/blfs-dev FAQ: http://www.linuxfromscratch.org/blfs/faq.html Unsubscribe: See the above information page
