hello TDF folks,
hello ODF Toolkit community,
i'm writing here as a Committer (fwiw) of the Apache ODF Toolkit
it turns out the ASF has voted to rename the Apache ODF Toolkit
(incubating) project to Apache ODF Toolkit (retired).
the ODF Toolkit project is important for the ODF ecosystem in general
and for LibreOffice in particular, since it contains not only the ODFDOM
Java library, but also the most accurate ODF Validator, which we use in
the LibreOffice test suite to check the ODF export filter.
so i'll propose to migrate the ODF Toolkit to The Document Foundation.
this is my (probably incomplete) understanding of the various different
parts of the project that need some action:
1. git: the repository of record is on GitHub, and will be changed to
read-only by the ASF:
the obvious options are:
a) move the git repository to gerrit.libreoffice.org
b) fork the GitHub project and continue hosting on GitHub
In any case, we should have a redirect from the old incubator project
to the new sources (perhaps a big red notice in README will be
2. the web site, in SVN (will also be changed to read-only):
the SVN repo contains some MarkDown files that are converted to
static HTML by some mysterious ASF-grown tool (Svante claims that
Perl scripts that rewrite references and a custom CMS are involved
somehow) that doesn't talk to anything other than the ASF SVN server
and which nobody in the ODF Toolkit project understands.
presumably there should be a way to preserve the (relatively small
and simple) content of the repo to either Wiki markup, or something
that some other MarkDown-to-HTML tool can understand; volunteers are
certainly welcome to help with this.
for a quick start it could also be an option to scrape the existing
HTML from http://incubator.apache.org/odftoolkit/ and replace the
internal URLs for consistency...
3. the domain "odftoolkit.org" - this currently redirects to
this domain would need to be transferred from ASF to TDF before it
(i don't know whether other domains related to ODF Toolkit exist;
apparently "odftoolkit.com" was registered at some time but it's
already expired/for sale)
4. mailing list: the "odf-...@incubator.apache.org" will be retired;
probably the amount of traffic is going to be quite small, hence
suggest to just use "libreoff...@freedesktop.org" for now; if the
traffic increases and becomes a problem a dedicated list can be
set up later.
5. currently the ASF JIRA is used as bug tracker, with project
there are currently 137 issues that are neither RESOLVED nor CLOSED.
so there are 2 decisions to be made here:
a) do we want a new component in "bugs.documentfoundation.org"
or use GitHub issues (only makes sense if GitHub is used for the
repo, of course)
b) should open issues be migrated? as long as they will be accessible
read-only in ASF JIRA (and i don't see any reason why not), i
don't see much value in it, since there aren't currently
developers available with time to fix the issues; if anybody feels
strongly about their issue they can re-create/copy it over
another point that we should probably discuss after the migration is
finished is whether the so-called "Simple API" should be removed from
ODFDOM due to being duplicative and unmaintained for years.
PS: thanks to Svante for proofreading this, if any errors remain it's my
To unsubscribe e-mail to: board-discuss+unsubscr...@documentfoundation.org
Posting guidelines + more: https://wiki.documentfoundation.org/Netiquette
List archive: https://listarchives.documentfoundation.org/www/board-discuss/