--- Matt Grimaldi <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> Darryl Shannon wrote:
> >
> > OK, I'll start. The age old debate: which would
> win, the USS
> > Enterprise-D, or an Imperial Star Destroyer? I
> mean, the star
> > destroyer is bigger, but it doesn't have any
> shields to speak of, nor
> > any photon torpedoes. Enterprise wins hands down.
> >
>
> The Star destroyer DOES have shields, and they seem
> to stop most of
> the lasers that hit them. True that they don't have
> any photon
> torpedoes, but there's a few things to consider:
> (1)How powerful are
> the
> StarWars lasers compared to Federation Phasers, and
> (2) The Star
> Destroyer
> has hundreds of fighter craft, each with their own
> "ion cannons" that
> could easily gang up on the Enterprise. Even though
> the Enterprise
> could
> probably fly circles around the Star Destroyer, it
> still drives like a
> cow
> when compared to fightercraft.
>
How did we get two sw vs st threads? I'm voting for
the feds: they've *got* to have far superior fire
control, if star wars fighter craft regularly beat up
on larger craft. Anyone play xvt? I'm not sure if
it's canon, but it sure isn't that hard to blow up a
star destroyer if you simply don't fly in a straight
line for too long. in star trek terms, everything in
star wars is manually targetted.
dean
__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Make international calls for as low as $.04/minute with Yahoo! Messenger
http://phonecard.yahoo.com/
