"John D. Giorgis" wrote: > > At 03:10 PM 9/27/01 -0700 Jeffrey Miller wrote: > >> > > > I don't disagree that often anti-Semitism can be the source of > >> > > > anti-Israeli commentary, but its not always the case - I doubt its > >> even > >> > > > the majority of the cases. The knee-jerk reaction of the staunch > >> > > > defenders to accuse anyone who criticizes the STATE of such feelings > >> is > >> > > > irresponsible nad serves only to halt intelligent conversation. > >> > > > > >> > > > >> > > Could you please document that with specific posts? > >> > > >> > No > >> > > >> > >> Care to withdraw the statement, then? > > > >No > > O.k. Could you at least, in the future, refrain from making inflammatory > statements that you aren't prepared to defend?
I don't think its inflammatory at all to say "Often when I see or hear people critisize israel, they're call anti-Semitic irregardless of the nature of their comments" Dan's poking and prodding for documentation is BS and is designed to either intimidate me and other people into shutting up by making me feel like I can participate in the conversation - I'm not going to bit at that one. documenting crap like that is neigh on impossible -j-
