I am a also member of an aquarium/tropical fish mailing list and there is
sort of an infamous lawsuit in progress about negative comments made via an
internet bulletin board that I though some of you might find interesting.
(and no, I am not suggesting anything that has to do with Brin-L!)

In a nutshell: several members of this certain aquatic mailing list made
remarks about the service that they received from an internet pet supply
company. These remarks were only their personal opinion about the service
that they had personally received.

The owner of this internet pet supply company has now sued the owner of the
website/ mailing list, several participants of the mailing list, CompuServe,
the Long Island Better Business Bureau, and anyone linking to the website
for $15,000,000 (yes, 15 MILLION).

Reading through the website and the history of the dispute (see link below)
, it is interesting to see how a company would rather spend thousands of
dollars pursuing legal action rather than spend hundreds to rectify the
complaints made by the few unhappy people who purchased merchandise from
them via the internet.

Anyway, the relevance here is that this case could potentially set a
precedent for free speech (or lack of) over the internet.

Personally, I think that the lawsuit will be dismissed, or at least I hope
that it is. Otherwise the courts could become clogged with lawsuits based on
any real or perceived negative comments made via the internet.

However, even if this is dismissed, at the very least, the defendants have
had to retain legal counsel, and I am sure that was not cheap - especially
being an out of state lawsuit.

http://petsforum.com/psw/Default.html

___________________________________________
  Gary L. Nunn
  Delaware Ohio

   "When there is no enemy within, the
    enemies outside cannot hurt you."
                  -African proverb

Reply via email to