Ho hum.

But you seem to think that Palestinians having the wherewithall for armed
resistance is a substantial breach of the peace process.  I say the article
is well crafted right-wing propaganda.

But for the sake of argument, lets assume that I accept it at face value.

What do you propose to do about it?

Give Sharon whatever he wants?

Imprison Arafat, impose concessions on Israel terms and an interim goverment
on Palestine.

Bear in mind, Bush is *on record* saying he wants a two-state solution.  A
two-state solution seems to pretty much be US policy, at least for now.


Me:
So, by your definition, the Palestinians can violate the agreements that
they have signed promising that they will limit their arsenals, and that
fact is "right-wing propaganda?"  At what point, exactly, would Palestinian
violations of the accords not be right wing propaganda?  When they were
using explosives they aren't supposed to have to kill Israeli
kindergardeners?  Oh, wait, that's already happening.  When they were
shipping heavy anti-tank weapons they aren't supposed to have into the
territories with the assistance of the Iranian government?  Oh, _that's_
already happening too.

For the sake of argument, I'll ignore the ludicrous description of a Scott
Shuger article in Slate as right-wing.  Have you ever even read Slate, by
any chance?  Do you have any idea where it falls on the political spectrum?
The fact that Michael Kinsley was its founding editor might possibly suggest
something to you.

But what is it that you think Sharon wants?  I'll tell you exactly what - he
wants Israeli civilians to no longer be murdered by Palestinian terrorists.
Apparently everyone but Jews is allowed to live in safety and defend
themselves when attacked.  Jews, though, have to sit there and take it.

Finally, I would point out that there are three major players in the
process - Bush, Sharon, and Arafat.  Bush has said he wants a two-state
solution.  Arafat says that in English but in Arabic repeatedly calls for
the destruction of Israel.  Sharon, however, is _also_ on record as
proposing a two-state solution.  He _also_ has publicly supported the
creation of a Palestinian state.  Only one of the three parties wants a
one-state solution.  It's not the US, and it's not the Israelis.

Gautam

Reply via email to