On Sun, Jul 21, 2002 at 02:01:12PM -0500, Dan Minette wrote:

> Do you also belive that you have no control over your actions at all,
> its just whatever the initial conditions and quantum fluctuations
> dictate?

That is an ambiguous question. What does it mean to have control over
one's actions? What constitutes one?

Rather than getting bogged down in semantic arguments, I will try to
answer by comparing to something else that is similarly ambigous.

Are you familiar with the drones in Iain Banks' Culture? For example, do
you remember Chamlis Amalk-ney, from _Player of Games_? I think I am in
control of my own actions in a similar way to how Chamlis is in control
of Chamlis' own actions. Chamlis is controlled by programming, very
complicated programming that responds to a multitude of outside stimuli,
a program that can modify itself, and a program that was developed
over many years with a great deal of input from other sapients and
from millions of events occurring in the rest of the universe, and a
program that had a bit of randomness intentionally included at the very
beginning.



-- 
"Erik Reuter" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>       http://www.erikreuter.net/

Reply via email to