At 09:59 10-2-2003 -0500, Jon Gabriel wrote:
It's already been a few *years* since the latest post in the _Glory Season_ review (sorry, I mean the in-depth analysis <GRIN> ), and I have reminded him of this unfinished business two or three times since then. He never showed any initiative to pick up where he left, so I don't think he'll mind if you finish the job. Actually, I don't think he should even *complain* if someone would want to finish what he started.My vote goes to David Brin's _Glory Season_. We started on reviewing that but never finished it; if we are going to do book reviews, we should at least first finish what we started.I think it's a good idea, but if Glory Season is chosen, I'll have to talk to JDG first since I don't want to step on his toes. He started the work on that book and may very well want to finish it himself.
Jeroen "Unfinished Business" van Baardwijk
Also, I'll add your vote to the tally, but if Glory Season is the book that's chosen, I'm not sure I'll do it.Then why tally votes, if your decision on whether to review a specific book will be based on whether you *like* the book, rather than on the outcome of the vote?
Only accepting the outcome of the vote if you like it is so... Bush-ist... <GRIN>
Would have to think about it and reread GS before deciding (don't worry, I read very quickly). It's the only book Dr. Brin has written that I didn't like and I'm not sure my heart would be in it.It happens to be my favourite Brin book. I haven't read all of his books yet (still two or three to go), but _Glory Season_ is the only one I've read *twice* already.
Jeroen "Unfinished Business" van Baardwijk
_________________________________________________________________________
Wonderful-World-of-Brin-L Website: http://www.Brin-L.com
_______________________________________________
http://www.mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin-l
