Sonja van Baardwijk-Holten answered George A:

> "G. D. Akin" wrote:
>
> > We pretty much decided that the public does have a right to know, but
not as
> > it is happening.  Those were live Marines, very much in harm's way.  We
need
> > to know about the fight and the Iraqi resistance, but we can learn of it
> > later (with a couple or few hours).  No one needs to see anyone get
killed,
> > which could easily happen.
>
> If it weren't so hard on the families of the soldiers I'd feel that we
maybe
> should get those scenes in close up, on a large screen with a repeat every
few
> minutes. Then let GWB tell us again how come that the war is necesarry.
War has
> become too clean, too remote, too abstract for my taste. Maybe if we bring
some
> of the horror that our ancestors must have felt whenever they had to fight
for
> their lives we might be a little less likely/gullible to go for the all
out war
> option when there is still some hope for a peacefull resolution.
>
> > Just some thoughts.
>
> Me too.
>
> Sonja

Your comment about war becoming "too clean, too remote, too abstract" is
valid.  For years we have been using aircraft and missiles to kill and
destroy from a distance--very clinical.  The Army and Marines bear the brunt
of real battle because they actually have to take and hold ground.

Read Joe Haleman's "Forever Peace" and his "soldierboys" to see the next
generation of "too clean, too remote, too abstract" weapons and warfare.

George A



_______________________________________________
http://www.mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin-l

Reply via email to