Charlie Bell wrote:
> 
> Really? I'm sure Native Americans, original Australians (especially 
> in  Tasmania where they were wiped out), the "fuzzywuzzies" who were 
> made  to build railways in Africa and so on would disagree with 
> that.  Britain has just as shameful a past in slavery and 
> extermination as  the French, Dutch, Belgians, Portugese... Maybe more.
> 
I think we must separate what was deliberate extermination,
accidental extermination and assimilation. The Portuguese Empire
had this crazy idea that half of the world was theirs, to
make them good catholics sudits of the King of Portugal.

The craziest thing is that they _almost_ succeeded, at an enormous
cost to Portugal itself. I've read somewhere that between 1500 and
1580 (or so, when Dom Sebastião vanished and Portugal was
anschlussed by Spain) the population of european Portugal was
reduced to _half_, as they desperately tried to grab half of
the world.

What I mean is that the portuguese genocide of brazilian natives
was either accidental (diseases) or assimilation. Each native
tribe that spontaneously converted to catholicism - and many of
them did, as the technology of the invaders was really 
impressive - was immediately accepted in equal terms with the 
portuguese colonists. They wouldn't be able to conquer such a
vast area in so little time otherwise - just to compare, by
1580 or so all coastline of Brazil was firmly secured in 
Portuguese control, and then they (and here I am almost replacing
"they" by "we"...) began digging to the inside.

OTOH, there were some episodes of deliberate genocide, with - as
usual (WTG! take note on this! Religion is evil!!!) - a theological
justification. Canibal tribes were considered soulless (how can a
canibal resurect on Judgment Day, when most of this flesh comes from
other people? It's absurd that God would resurect a man with missing
parts, so the natural conclusion is that canibals don't have a soul),
and were fair game to extermination.

Alberto Monteiro

_______________________________________________
http://www.mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin-l

Reply via email to