Thank you, I shall ask the os-prober maintainers instead, it sounds like 
regular mount (or something else) would be better to use for that purpose after 
perhaps testing it's available, I'd guess grub-mount might have been designed 
to use in the minimal early boot environment with the limited resources 
available at that point.


May 13, 2024, 21:59 by phco...@gmail.com:

> We don't maintain os-prober. As for grub-mount it was never meant to be fast 
> and certainly isn't 
>
> Le lun. 13 mai 2024, 22:47, stratus--- via Bug reports for the GRand Unified 
> Bootloader <> bug-grub@gnu.org> > a écrit :
>
>> Dear Grub maintainers, myself and others on the Artix forum have experienced 
>> problems with os-prober running very slowly. The issue seems to occur in 
>> other distros as well, and the same subject has come up before in the past:
>>  >> https://forum.artixlinux.org/index.php/topic,6818.msg41493
>>  It appears that grub-mount uses a FUSE mount which requires a specific 
>> implementation for different filesystems. When the partitions are mounted 
>> with grub-mount, file reading operations are vastly slower than when mounted 
>> by the normal mount command. This is even worse on BTRFS than with EXT4, and 
>> it looks like NTFS is probably very slow too. This can be easily tested by 
>> using grub-mount to mount a partition then seeing how long it takes to copy 
>> some files over compared with a normal mount. And to further obscure the 
>> issue, it also appears to depend on how much searching os-prober has to do 
>> before  finding out the information it needs, some distros like Devuan seem 
>> to yield this quickly so there still isn't any real delay, but Arch takes 
>> much longer and probably Windows too it appears.
>>  I sometimes use gvfs-gphoto2 to transfer pictures and videos (some of which 
>> may be several GB in size) from my camera which uses a FUSE implementation 
>> and that doesn't have especially slow transfer speeds.
>>  I wonder if you might be able to fix this sometime, or if you think the 
>> issue lies outside of grub, provide advice on who to "bug" about this 
>> instead.
>>  Best wishes!
>>


  • os-prober slow... stratus--- via Bug reports for the GRand Unified Bootloader
    • Re: os-pr... Vladimir 'phcoder' Serbinenko
      • Re: o... stratus--- via Bug reports for the GRand Unified Bootloader

Reply via email to