Frank Ludolph wrote:
> Glynn Foster wrote:
>> I agree there's benefits to each approach. My preference is that a 
>> software selection should appear after the Disks screen, since the 
>> user could dynamically check and uncheck selections to see if they can 
>> get under the current disk size (as opposed to having to go back to 
>> adjust their software selection if a disk with enough size isn't 
>> available).
>>
> While 'after' does help fit software onto a disk as you suggest, 
> 'before' helps to properly size a new partition. All of which might be 
> moot given what Shawn has been saying...

If you can figure out:
* how to get about a hundred megabytes (I'm guessing here) of temporary 
space
* which packages are part of the live cd that won't be part of the 
installed system
* which "unpackaged" files are on the live cd that won't be part of the 
system
* which packages are to be installed into the image

...then you can get a reasonably close aggregate install size.

Once these three things happen in pkg(5):
* SAT solver integration
* new Catalog format integration
* api addition to get operation sizes

I want to be clear that I wasn't trying to suggest that the 
functionality you're trying to have isn't useful or possible, but it is 
very difficult given the network-based install angle + the cpio image of 
the live media.

If this was a giant install dvd (not live media) and you weren't 
performing a network-based install, things would be different...

Cheers,
-- 
Shawn Walker

Reply via email to