Hi, George, 

> -----Original Message-----
> From: George Paci [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
> Sent: Friday, October 22, 2004 3:23 PM
> To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
> Subject: Re: Feeling the need to shout was RE: [XP] Re: Fear 
> and Loathing Cards
> 
> 
> Kay Pentecost wrote (on 15-Oct-2004):
> 
>  > [Ron Jeffries wrote:]
>  >> On Friday, October 15, 2004, at 8:51:48 PM, Kay Pentecost wrote:
>  >>> But manipulation is not always a bad thing.
> 
>  >>> You can, for example, manipulate a person into understanding that
>  >>> the reason for your feedback was concern for his abilities, and a
>  >>> way of helping, not hurting.  If you succeed in that 
> manipulation,
>  >>> you may have a team member who can now learn without feeling
>  >>> threatened, and a team at peace... or would that be a bad thing?
> 
>  >> I've encountered people who think that manipulation is a 
> bad thing.
>  >> Frankly, it seems to me that whenever we express our opinion with
>  >> intent to offer something of value to others, we are attempting to
>  >> influence them. Is that manipulation? Seems to me that it is.
> 
>  > I think it's a form of manipulation.
> 
> I disagree strongly (though not, evidently, promptly).

No, not hardly promptly. <grin>

> 
> People commonly use the words "manipulation" and "manipulative" to
> describe influence that involves:
>    (1) dishonesty or hiding real motives; and
>    (2) getting the influenced person to do something they wouldn't
>        choose to do otherwise (i.e. of their own free will)

Yes, people do.  And yet, in this thread, I hope I've made it clear (and I
think I have, at least to Dale) lying and deceit are not my definition of
"manipulation."

I haven't presented a definition of manipulation.  I think this might be a
good time to say how *I*'m defining manipulation:  it's the skillful use of
mental techniques to change a person's state or actions.

By mental, I mean that the action of manipulation is cosidered, thought-full
and deliberate  -- not, in otherwords. mindless.


> 
>  > Everything we do manipulates to some level.  Smiling at someone in
>  > the street, complimenting a stranger, presenting 
> intelligent options
>  > to ignorant behaviour, that all may cause a response from someone
>  > else.
> 
> Influence, influence, influence, in my book.

Fine.  

  But not manipulation,
> since there's no dishonesty in a smile (unless it's the lead-in to a
> con game),

*unless*


 a compliment (unless you're trying to wheedle something
> more out of them than the expected smalltalk),

*unless*

> and waxing intelligent
> in the face of ignorance (unless you're actually trying to influence
> onlookers, as opposed to the ignoramus).

*unless*

And in each of those "unlesses" you seem to *me* to be giving examples of
doing exatly what I saw is manipulation.

> 
> Nor is it clear how to make a stranger do something definite with a
> simple compliment or smile (yes, even yours, Kay). 

hum.... *especially* mine, perhaps!!


> And presenting
> options is just about the complete opposite of controlling someone.

There is an edge, at least, of control in manipulation.

> 
> Note that I'm not saying manipulation can never be good,

Cool!  Then we're in agreement, because I'm saying that manipulation isn't
always bad!

 just that it
> always involves dishonesty of some sort and reducing someone's
> autonomy -- which, of course, are usually wrong.

Yes, that seems to be the consensus "manipulation is bad" because it
involves lying, and lying is bad.  

> 
>  > I started studying NLP because I wanted a defense against 
> other people's
>  > negative manipulation.  I stayed with it as long as I have 
> because I've
>  > learned skills that help me feel good, be productive, and hame more
>  > choices... and because it's taught me to recognize *some* 
> of the effect I
>  > have on others.
>  >
>  > I like having a good effect on people... I like helping 
> them find more
>  > choices.
> 
> Shifting topic: one theory of two-person win/lose games (Conway's, I
> think) defines /losing/ a game as being in a position where you have
> no moves (i.e. no choices).

Interesting.  I hope that most of my interactions with inteligent, caring
people are win/win.
I know there are times when I am not dealing with "intelligent" or "caring"
people -- sometimes I really feel like I *lost* and they *won* -- I know one
particular manager who learned all his managerial skills by watching
"Survivor" -- I'm sure he thinks he won.  But since I didn't have to resort
to being cruel or diminishing *them* -- I think I won too.

Now, I wonder.  Did they win?  Or did I?  Or did both of us?

Kay





To Post a message, send it to:   [EMAIL PROTECTED]

To Unsubscribe, send a blank message to: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

ad-free courtesy of objectmentor.com 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/extremeprogramming/

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 



Reply via email to