Kay Pentecost wrote (on 15-Oct-2004):
> [Ron Jeffries wrote:]
>> On Friday, October 15, 2004, at 8:51:48 PM, Kay Pentecost wrote:
>>> But manipulation is not always a bad thing.
>>> You can, for example, manipulate a person into understanding that
>>> the reason for your feedback was concern for his abilities, and a
>>> way of helping, not hurting. If you succeed in that manipulation,
>>> you may have a team member who can now learn without feeling
>>> threatened, and a team at peace... or would that be a bad thing?
>> I've encountered people who think that manipulation is a bad thing.
>> Frankly, it seems to me that whenever we express our opinion with
>> intent to offer something of value to others, we are attempting to
>> influence them. Is that manipulation? Seems to me that it is.
> I think it's a form of manipulation.
I disagree strongly (though not, evidently, promptly).
People commonly use the words "manipulation" and "manipulative" to
describe influence that involves:
(1) dishonesty or hiding real motives; and
(2) getting the influenced person to do something they wouldn't
choose to do otherwise (i.e. of their own free will)
> Everything we do manipulates to some level. Smiling at someone in
> the street, complimenting a stranger, presenting intelligent options
> to ignorant behaviour, that all may cause a response from someone
> else.
Influence, influence, influence, in my book. But not manipulation,
since there's no dishonesty in a smile (unless it's the lead-in to a
con game), a compliment (unless you're trying to wheedle something
more out of them than the expected smalltalk), and waxing intelligent
in the face of ignorance (unless you're actually trying to influence
onlookers, as opposed to the ignoramus).
Nor is it clear how to make a stranger do something definite with a
simple compliment or smile (yes, even yours, Kay). And presenting
options is just about the complete opposite of controlling someone.
Note that I'm not saying manipulation can never be good, just that it
always involves dishonesty of some sort and reducing someone's
autonomy -- which, of course, are usually wrong.
> I started studying NLP because I wanted a defense against other people's
> negative manipulation. I stayed with it as long as I have because I've
> learned skills that help me feel good, be productive, and hame more
> choices... and because it's taught me to recognize *some* of the effect I
> have on others.
>
> I like having a good effect on people... I like helping them find more
> choices.
Shifting topic: one theory of two-person win/lose games (Conway's, I
think) defines /losing/ a game as being in a position where you have
no moves (i.e. no choices).
--George Paci <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
A surprising number of autistic people are borderline programmers.
To Post a message, send it to: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To Unsubscribe, send a blank message to: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
ad-free courtesy of objectmentor.com
Yahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/extremeprogramming/
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/