The GPS coordinates I cited, 42.88887,-76.72518, are of a green channel marker 
on the Google Maps aerial photo in the right direction from Talcott's place 
(aka Townline Rd) in the NW corner of Springport and in the right direction 
from Wolffy's near the south end of Lower Lake Rd near the SE corner of Seneca 
Falls. I don't know how old the aerial photo was or whether those markers ever 
get moved, so I can't argue about whose coordinates are better. This location 
is somewhat closer than Suan's coordinates to the Talcott viewing spot, which 
is the closest land. My impression was that Wolffy's was considerably farther 
(almost twice as far on the map using my coordinates). There was also heat 
shimmer until late in the day when I viewed from the west, which had not been a 
factor from the east, where the light had been good until past noon. 

Early this morning I watched from Cayuga Lake State Park, which is a bit 
farther north on Lower Lake Rd. Even though it is even farther from marker 49, 
and sun glare is a big issue in the morning, I gambled that I could see more of 
the lake in case the bird went hunting. Viewing from the elevated level of the 
road at sunrise I had heat shimmer but I could recognize the backlit Booby on 
channel marker 49 because its shape and size were familiar to me, especially 
compared to the Great Black-backed Gull who shared the platform. About 7:24 a 
boat passed very close carrying two standing guys fishing. Shortly after the 
gull flushed, so did the Booby, which to my great fortune flew northwest toward 
me low over the water. Eventually some trees which had blocked the sun for me 
also blocked the view of the flying bird, and I had to move, but at 7:33 I had 
an excellent profile scope view of it still/again flying NW. Then its low 
flight took it behind the small patch of shoreline cattails for me, and I had 
to move again. I scanned more, and at 7:40 I discovered it sitting on the water 
far to the NNE amid considerable shimmer. The all-brown head, neck & body, the 
long level back, the slope of about 30° from the "hip" down to the water at the 
tail, and the long gleamingly whitish bill were distinctive (neither cormorant 
nor coot). After about 10 minutes of just looking around, the Booby began 
preening, then bathing, which involved alternately and awkwardly raising each 
long, narrow, sharply bent wing into the air while the body rolled sideways 
revealing its white belly and wing linings. Next it took flight again, going SE 
and shaking water off a couple times, though not as dramatically as an Osprey 
does. This flight the Booby's bill was angled a bit down like a Concorde jet, 
so I had hopes it was hunting and might dive but no such luck. Again my view 
was temporarily blocked, this time by the parked police boat. Then I didn't 
know which side of the broad sun glare it was on. By a few minutes after 8, I 
determined that it was back on green channel marker 49, which no longer had 
people nearby. I knew that if the bird had fed, it might not fly again all day, 
so even though I never saw it dive, I declared victory and went home.
--Dave Nutter
PS Pasted at the bottom is my original message from the 20th about getting 
permission. I hope that this version is legible from various re-posting and 
archiving sources.

> On Sep 22, 2016, at 9:55 AM, Suan Hsi Yong <> wrote:
> On Thu, Sep 22, 2016 at 8:31 AM, Peter < 
> <>> wrote:
> Folks - a question about the Booby. Is it more easily seen from Lower Lake 
> Rd. near Seneca Falls (west side of lake) or from the village of Cayuga (east 
> side of lake).
> Or perhaps it depends on the bird's mood? (smile)
> Depends on the sun.
> The GPS coordinates I got when I was about 50 feet from buoy 49 was 
> 42.886767N 76.727776W.
> As you can see from Google Maps, it's almost exactly halfway across the lake, 
> a little closer to the east shore.
> That bird knew how to choose a buoy farthest from land :-D.
> Suan 

I had been out of town, so late this morning was my first chance to look for 
the refound Brown Booby. I was successful. It was on the green channel marker 
located at 42.88887,-76.72518. I first went to the location many have described 
as "Townline Road" but some have had trouble locating because there are 
Townline Roads along many township borders. To be more informative, this refers 
to the Aurelius-Springport Townline Road next to the railroad crossing of 
NYS-90 north of Union Springs. 

HOWEVER, going west from NYS-90 this is not a road. As I was pointedly informed 
by the owner, Steve Talcott, it is a PRIVATE DRIVEWAY (in fact there is a small 
sign to that effect near NYS-90). He does not appreciate his land being taken 
for granted as if it were a public park. He would appreciate being politely 
asked for permission to bird from there. His number is 315-730-3571. Although 
the Booby was not being particularly exciting or obvious I showed it to him and 
explained how special it is. He granted permission by phone for a group of 
birders from Cornell, and welcomed them, and when I left I believe we were on 
good terms. Please don't screw it up.

I stayed for over 3 hours hoping to see it fly and hunt. It didn't. The light 
got worse. I took a break to get food from the Nice-n-Easy, and drive to Lower 
Lake Road. The bird was still on the platform of the channel marker and 
remained there for another 3 1/2 hours including sunset. Lazy thing. I guess it 
did all its feeding and most of its preening earlier in the morning. It did 
stand up and stretch a few times, so I know it has proper wings. And it 
defecated several times, so presumably it has been eating. So far I have no 
reason to believe it is unhealthy. It just surprised me by how sedentary it 
was. Perhaps that's how it evaded detection for almost 3 weeks.
--Dave Nutter


Cayugabirds-L List Info:


Please submit your observations to eBird:


Reply via email to