Jason, I played with this some today and I think a lightbulb went off for me. The assumed scenario for cBarge + custom-cptone is:
1. PhoneC calls shared line on PhoneA/PhoneB (Phones A and B are registered to CME) 2. Phone A answers on shared line 3. Phone B seizes line (remote in use) and selects the cBarge softkey 4. At this point the custom-cptone for JOIN should be played out 5. Phone B disconnects from call 6. Our assumption is that the custom-cptone for LEAVE should be played out I have always had the same experience you noted. Which is: Step 4 works fine, no problem. Step 6 never works. IOW, I never hear a leave tone. I tested different configs for custom-cptone, even though doing so didn't make much sense. The behavior is the same. You do want to make sure that the frequency is different. The cadence can be the same as far as I can tell, but it can be diff too. Not really all that relevant to the question. I then tested MML using the same cptone setup and I do get JOIN and LEAVE tones. A clue that the voice-class assignment to the dspfarm is healthy. I then tested ad-hoc conference from one of the phones. Only test 3 party conference. I hear a JOIN tone when the 3rd party is added. I DO NOT hear a LEAVE tone when that third party disconnects. At this point it dawns on me what is going on. For giggles, I did another set of tests. I tested ad-hoc with 4 parties. I also tested a barge-in and then an ad-hoc add for a fourth party. If any single party (save the initiator) leaves that ad-hoc conference, a tone is played out to remaining parties (which is now 3). If one of the remaining three parties leaves (except for the conference initiator) then there is NO tone played out to the remaining two parties. Based on observed behavior, I am thinking that things are behaving as designed. The custom-cptones are associated with the dspfarm profile. When you transition from a 2-party call to a 3+ party call, you are involving the dspfarm and getting the tones. When you drop to a 2-party call, you are dropping the need for a dspfarm and the call becomes point-to-point. So, if the dspfarm was attempting to playout tones, it is no longer involved in the media path. So, the absence of the LEAVE tone seams (IMO) to be expected behavior. Assuming that one accepts that the observed behavior is expected then the question requirement to playout a tone when a party leaves is bogus. If I hit this in the real lab and the requirement says a tone must be played when the line is barged AND when the barging party leaves, I would bring it up to the proctor as a bogus requirement. The dspfarm is removed from the call at the point where the barging party leaves and is no longer in the media path. If, on the other hand, it simply says parties on the call should hear a tone when the line is barged then there is no problem. -Bill -- William Bell blog: http://ucguerrilla.com twitter: @ucguerrilla On Feb 17, 2013, at 9:45 PM, Jason Lee wrote: > I'll give it a go tomorrow. I already reverted my pod this evening. I'll be > doing another lab tomorrow, so I should be able to test this put by tomorrow > afternoon. > > Sent from my iPad > > On Feb 17, 2013, at 9:14 PM, Bill <whl...@gmail.com> wrote: > >> I think Justin might be on to it but it has been a while since I have done >> this in the lab. >> >> >> >> Sent from my iPad >> >> On Feb 17, 2013, at 3:06 PM, Justin Carney <justin.s.car...@gmail.com> wrote: >> >>> I haven't tested this recently, but it may help to make the join/leave >>> tones use different frequencies, as well as using different time intervals >>> for the cadence. >>> >>> I'm not sure why you're getting these strange results (two tones on join >>> when your cadence only shows one and no tone on leave), but there may be >>> some strange "feature" (or bug) that has to do with both join and leave >>> using the same frequency. >>> >>> voice class custom-cptone leave >>> dualtone conference >>> frequency 300 >>> cadence 400 500 600 >>> ! >>> voice class custom-cptone join >>> dualtone conference >>> frequency 700 >>> cadence 800 >>> >>> -Justin >>> >>> On Sun, Feb 17, 2013 at 1:56 PM, William Bell <b...@ucguerrilla.com> wrote: >>> I don't have an answer for you. However, I can confirm that I have noticed >>> the same behavior. When I have associated custom tones for join/leave >>> events, I only hear the tone on join. Nada on leave. I haven't figured it >>> out yet. >>> >>> >>> -Bill >>> -- >>> William Bell >>> blog: http://ucguerrilla.com >>> twitter: @ucguerrilla >>> >>> >>> >>> On Feb 17, 2013, at 12:39 PM, Jason Lee wrote: >>> >>>> All, >>>> >>>> I have continually struggled with custom tones for a while now. I'm >>>> working on the 5LB Lab 1 today and have the preserve CBarge configuration >>>> in place. As I have it configured I'm expecting to hear one tone on entry >>>> and 2 when a call exits the call. >>>> >>>> What I'm actually hearing is 2 on join and nothing on leave. >>>> >>>> Here's the config. Can anyone see anything that I'm doing wrong? >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> r2800-2j-b#sh run >>>> Building configuration... >>>> >>>> >>>> Current configuration : 9095 bytes >>>> ! >>>> ! Last configuration change at 17:35:03 GMT Sun Feb 17 2013 >>>> ! >>>> version 12.4 >>>> service timestamps debug datetime msec >>>> service timestamps log datetime msec >>>> no service password-encryption >>>> ! >>>> hostname r2800-2j-b >>>> ! >>>> boot-start-marker >>>> boot system flash >>>> boot-end-marker >>>> ! >>>> card type e1 0 1 >>>> card type t1 1 >>>> logging message-counter syslog >>>> enable password cisco >>>> ! >>>> no aaa new-model >>>> clock timezone GMT 0 >>>> no network-clock-participate slot 1 >>>> network-clock-participate wic 1 >>>> network-clock-select 1 E1 0/1/0 >>>> ! >>>> dot11 syslog >>>> ip source-route >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ip cef >>>> ip dhcp excluded-address 192.168.106.0 192.168.106.119 >>>> ip dhcp excluded-address 192.168.106.130 192.168.106.255 >>>> ! >>>> ip dhcp pool phn2 >>>> host 192.168.106.130 255.255.255.0 >>>> client-identifier 01c8.f9f9.d739.77 >>>> default-router 192.168.106.1 >>>> option 150 ip 192.168.100.100 192.168.100.101 >>>> ! >>>> ip dhcp pool voip >>>> network 192.168.106.0 255.255.255.0 >>>> option 150 ip 192.168.100.100 192.168.100.101 >>>> default-router 192.168.106.1 >>>> ! >>>> --More-- >>>> .Feb 17 17:35:03.037: %SYS-5-CONFIG_I: Configured from console ! e >>>> no ip domain lookup >>>> no ipv6 cef >>>> ! >>>> multilink bundle-name authenticated >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> isdn switch-type primary-net5 >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> voice service voip >>>> allow-connections h323 to h323 >>>> allow-connections h323 to sip >>>> allow-connections sip to h323 >>>> allow-connections sip to sip >>>> fax protocol cisco >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> voice class codec 1 >>>> codec preference 1 g711ulaw >>>> codec preference 2 g729r8 >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> voice class h323 1 >>>> h225 timeout tcp establish 3 >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> voice class custom-cptone leave >>>> dualtone conference >>>> frequency 300 >>>> cadence 400 400 400 >>>> ! >>>> voice class custom-cptone join >>>> dualtone conference >>>> frequency 300 >>>> cadence 400 >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> voice translation-rule 1 >>>> rule 1 /.+\(....\)$/ /\1/ >>>> ! >>>> voice translation-rule 9 >>>> rule 1 /^[0-8]/ /9\0/ >>>> ! >>>> voice translation-rule 23 >>>> rule 1 /2.../ /001202555\0/ type any international plan any isdn >>>> rule 2 /3.../ /001408387\0/ type any international plan any isdn >>>> ! >>>> voice translation-rule 97 >>>> rule 4 // // type any subscriber plan any isdn >>>> ! >>>> voice translation-rule 910 >>>> rule 4 // // type any national plan any isdn >>>> ! >>>> voice translation-rule 911 >>>> rule 4 // // type any unknown plan any unknown >>>> ! >>>> voice translation-rule 971 >>>> rule 1 /4.../ /+44207796\0/ >>>> rule 4 // // type any subscriber plan any isdn >>>> ! >>>> voice translation-rule 9011 >>>> rule 4 // // type any international plan any isdn >>>> ! >>>> voice translation-rule 9101 >>>> rule 1 /4.../ /+44207796\0/ >>>> rule 4 // // type any national plan any isdn >>>> ! >>>> voice translation-rule 9111 >>>> rule 1 /4...$/ /7796\0/ >>>> rule 4 // // type any unknown plan any unknown >>>> ! >>>> voice translation-rule 90111 >>>> rule 1 /4.../ /+44207796\0/ >>>> rule 4 // // type any international plan any isdn >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> voice translation-profile 23 >>>> translate called 23 >>>> ! >>>> voice translation-profile 9 >>>> translate calling 1 >>>> translate called 9 >>>> ! >>>> voice translation-profile 9011 >>>> translate calling 90111 >>>> translate called 9011 >>>> ! >>>> voice translation-profile 910 >>>> translate calling 9101 >>>> translate called 910 >>>> ! >>>> voice translation-profile 911 >>>> translate calling 9111 >>>> translate called 911 >>>> ! >>>> voice translation-profile 97 >>>> translate calling 971 >>>> translate called 97 >>>> ! >>>> voice translation-profile strip >>>> translate called 1 >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> voice-card 0 >>>> dsp services dspfarm >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> archive >>>> log config >>>> hidekeys >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> controller E1 0/1/0 >>>> pri-group timeslots 1-3,16 >>>> ! >>>> controller E1 0/1/1 >>>> ! >>>> controller T1 1/0 >>>> cablelength long 0db >>>> ! >>>> controller T1 1/1 >>>> cablelength long 0db >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> interface Loopback0 >>>> ip address 192.168.96.2 255.255.255.255 >>>> h323-gateway voip bind srcaddr 192.168.96.2 >>>> ! >>>> interface GigabitEthernet0/0 >>>> no ip address >>>> duplex auto >>>> speed auto >>>> ! >>>> interface GigabitEthernet0/0.105 >>>> encapsulation dot1Q 105 native >>>> ip address 192.168.105.1 255.255.255.0 >>>> ! >>>> interface GigabitEthernet0/0.106 >>>> encapsulation dot1Q 106 >>>> ip address 192.168.106.1 255.255.255.0 >>>> ! >>>> interface Service-Engine0/0 >>>> ip unnumbered GigabitEthernet0/0.106 >>>> service-module ip address 192.168.106.2 255.255.255.0 >>>> service-module ip default-gateway 192.168.106.1 >>>> ! >>>> interface GigabitEthernet0/1 >>>> no ip address >>>> shutdown >>>> duplex auto >>>> speed auto >>>> ! >>>> interface FastEthernet0/3/0 >>>> shutdown >>>> ! >>>> interface FastEthernet0/3/1 >>>> shutdown >>>> ! >>>> interface FastEthernet0/3/2 >>>> shutdown >>>> ! >>>> interface FastEthernet0/3/3 >>>> shutdown >>>> ! >>>> interface Serial0/0/0 >>>> no ip address >>>> encapsulation frame-relay IETF >>>> no fair-queue >>>> frame-relay lmi-type ansi >>>> ip rsvp bandwidth >>>> ! >>>> interface Serial0/0/0.1 point-to-point >>>> description FR-WAN INTERFACE - DLCI 102 >>>> ip address 192.168.111.10 255.255.255.252 >>>> shutdown >>>> frame-relay interface-dlci 102 >>>> ip rsvp bandwidth 64 >>>> ! >>>> interface Serial0/0/1 >>>> no ip address >>>> shutdown >>>> clock rate 2000000 >>>> ! >>>> interface Serial0/1/0:15 >>>> no ip address >>>> encapsulation hdlc >>>> isdn switch-type primary-net5 >>>> isdn incoming-voice voice >>>> isdn bchan-number-order ascending >>>> isdn outgoing display-ie >>>> no cdp enable >>>> ! >>>> interface Vlan1 >>>> no ip address >>>> ! >>>> router ospf 1 >>>> log-adjacency-changes >>>> network 192.168.0.0 0.0.255.255 area 0 >>>> ! >>>> ip forward-protocol nd >>>> ip route 0.0.0.0 0.0.0.0 Serial0/0/0.1 >>>> ip route 192.168.106.2 255.255.255.255 Service-Engine0/0 >>>> ip http server >>>> no ip http secure-server >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> nls resp-timeout 1 >>>> cpd cr-id 1 >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> control-plane >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> voice-port 0/1/0:15 >>>> translation-profile incoming strip >>>> ! >>>> voice-port 0/2/0 >>>> ! >>>> voice-port 0/2/1 >>>> ! >>>> voice-port 0/2/2 >>>> ! >>>> voice-port 0/2/3 >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> sccp local Loopback0 >>>> sccp ccm 192.168.106.1 identifier 3 version 7.0 >>>> sccp ccm 192.168.100.100 identifier 2 version 7.0 >>>> sccp ccm 192.168.100.101 identifier 1 version 7.0 >>>> sccp >>>> ! >>>> sccp ccm group 1 >>>> bind interface Loopback0 >>>> associate ccm 1 priority 1 >>>> associate ccm 2 priority 2 >>>> associate ccm 3 priority 3 >>>> associate profile 3 register sc-mtp-rsvp >>>> associate profile 2 register sc-conf >>>> associate profile 1 register sc-xcode >>>> keepalive timeout 3 >>>> switchover method immediate >>>> switchback method immediate >>>> ! >>>> dspfarm profile 1 transcode >>>> codec g711ulaw >>>> codec g711alaw >>>> codec g729ar8 >>>> codec g729abr8 >>>> codec g729r8 >>>> maximum sessions 4 >>>> associate application SCCP >>>> ! >>>> dspfarm profile 2 conference >>>> codec g711ulaw >>>> codec g711alaw >>>> codec g729ar8 >>>> codec g729abr8 >>>> codec g729r8 >>>> codec g729br8 >>>> maximum sessions 2 >>>> conference-join custom-cptone join >>>> conference-leave custom-cptone leave >>>> associate application SCCP >>>> ! >>>> dspfarm profile 3 mtp >>>> codec g729r8 >>>> rsvp >>>> maximum sessions software 100 >>>> associate application SCCP >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> dial-peer voice 911 pots >>>> translation-profile outgoing 911 >>>> destination-pattern 999$ >>>> port 0/1/0:15 >>>> forward-digits all >>>> ! >>>> dial-peer voice 97 pots >>>> translation-profile outgoing 97 >>>> destination-pattern 9[1-9].......$ >>>> port 0/1/0:15 >>>> forward-digits 8 >>>> ! >>>> dial-peer voice 910 pots >>>> translation-profile outgoing 910 >>>> destination-pattern 91[2-9].........$ >>>> port 0/1/0:15 >>>> forward-digits 11 >>>> ! >>>> dial-peer voice 9011 pots >>>> translation-profile outgoing 9011 >>>> destination-pattern 900T >>>> port 0/1/0:15 >>>> prefix 00 >>>> ! >>>> dial-peer voice 1 pots >>>> incoming called-number . >>>> direct-inward-dial >>>> ! >>>> dial-peer voice 2 voip >>>> translation-profile incoming 9 >>>> destination-pattern 4...$ >>>> voice-class codec 1 >>>> voice-class h323 1 >>>> session target ipv4:192.168.100.101 >>>> incoming called-number . >>>> dtmf-relay h245-alphanumeric >>>> no vad >>>> ! >>>> dial-peer voice 3 voip >>>> preference 1 >>>> destination-pattern 4...$ >>>> voice-class codec 1 >>>> voice-class h323 1 >>>> session target ipv4:192.168.100.100 >>>> dtmf-relay h245-alphanumeric >>>> no vad >>>> ! >>>> dial-peer voice 999 pots >>>> ! >>>> dial-peer voice 4600 voip >>>> destination-pattern 4600$ >>>> session protocol sipv2 >>>> session target ipv4:192.168.106.2 >>>> dtmf-relay sip-notify >>>> codec g711ulaw >>>> no vad >>>> ! >>>> dial-peer voice 23 pots >>>> translation-profile outgoing 23 >>>> destination-pattern [23]...$ >>>> port 0/1/0:15 >>>> forward-digits all >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> sip-ua >>>> mwi-server ipv4:192.168.106.2 expires 3600 port 5060 transport udp >>>> unsolicited >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> gatekeeper >>>> shutdown >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> telephony-service >>>> sdspfarm units 3 >>>> conference hardware >>>> srst mode auto-provision all >>>> srst ephone template 1 >>>> srst dn template 1 >>>> srst dn line-mode octo >>>> max-ephones 25 >>>> max-dn 40 no-reg >>>> ip source-address 192.168.106.1 port 2000 >>>> time-zone 21 >>>> time-format 24 >>>> voicemail 4600 >>>> max-conferences 8 gain -6 >>>> transfer-system full-consult >>>> secondary-dialtone 9 >>>> create cnf-files version-stamp 7960 Feb 16 2013 20:47:40 >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ephone-dn-template 1 >>>> call-forward busy 4600 >>>> call-forward noan 4600 timeout 10 >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ephone-template 1 >>>> softkeys remote-in-use Newcall CBarge >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ephone-dn 1 octo-line >>>> number 4001 >>>> description +442077964001 >>>> name +442077964001 >>>> ephone-dn-template 1 >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ephone-dn 2 octo-line >>>> number 4000 >>>> description 4000 >>>> name 4000 >>>> ephone-dn-template 1 >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ephone-dn 3 octo-line >>>> number 4002 >>>> description +442077964002 >>>> name +442077964002 >>>> ephone-dn-template 1 >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ephone-dn 20 octo-line >>>> number A02 no-reg primary >>>> conference ad-hoc >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ephone 1 >>>> privacy off >>>> privacy-button >>>> device-security-mode none >>>> mac-address C8F9.F9D7.545D >>>> ephone-template 1 >>>> button 1:1 2:2 >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ephone 2 >>>> device-security-mode none >>>> mac-address C8F9.F9D7.3977 >>>> ephone-template 1 >>>> button 1:3 2:2 >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> ! >>>> line con 0 >>>> line aux 0 >>>> line 194 >>>> no activation-character >>>> no exec >>>> transport preferred none >>>> transport input all >>>> transport output pad telnet rlogin lapb-ta mop udptn v120 ssh >>>> line vty 0 4 >>>> password cisco >>>> login >>>> ! >>>> scheduler allocate 20000 1000 >>>> ntp server 192.168.96.10 >>>> end >>>> >>>> r2800-2j-b# >>>> _______________________________________________ >>>> For more information regarding industry leading CCIE Lab training, please >>>> visit www.ipexpert.com >>>> >>>> Are you a CCNP or CCIE and looking for a job? Check out >>>> www.PlatinumPlacement.com >>> >>> >>> _______________________________________________ >>> For more information regarding industry leading CCIE Lab training, please >>> visit www.ipexpert.com >>> >>> Are you a CCNP or CCIE and looking for a job? Check out >>> www.PlatinumPlacement.com >>> >>> _______________________________________________ >>> For more information regarding industry leading CCIE Lab training, please >>> visit www.ipexpert.com >>> >>> Are you a CCNP or CCIE and looking for a job? Check out >>> www.PlatinumPlacement.com >> _______________________________________________ >> For more information regarding industry leading CCIE Lab training, please >> visit www.ipexpert.com >> >> Are you a CCNP or CCIE and looking for a job? Check out >> www.PlatinumPlacement.com > _______________________________________________ > For more information regarding industry leading CCIE Lab training, please > visit www.ipexpert.com > > Are you a CCNP or CCIE and looking for a job? Check out > www.PlatinumPlacement.com
_______________________________________________ For more information regarding industry leading CCIE Lab training, please visit www.ipexpert.com Are you a CCNP or CCIE and looking for a job? Check out www.PlatinumPlacement.com
