***  For details on how to be removed from this list visit the  ***
***          CCP4 home page http://www.ccp4.ac.uk         ***


On Fri, Nov 04, 2005 at 03:31:09PM -0600, Mischa Machius wrote:
> 
> I would really be interested in knowing what percentage of people  
> still uses text-based email programs. I guess most of us use email  
> clients with GUI's, either on Linux, Windows, or Mac. I don't see  
> much difference between a GUI (email client) that connects to an  
> email server and a GUI (browser) that connects to a central BB  
> database.
> 

Thats an easy one: with email, the user has complete flow control.
How I handle whats dumped to /var/spool/mail is completely up to me: I
can filter certain parts/messages to certain folders, flag certain
messages however I'd like, PGP sign/encrypt my messages, etc.  With a
forum, you're limited by the fronted presented to the user that
actually accesses the data.

> Likewise, I don't see much difference between hitting "g" and
> clicking the "Reply" button.

True, the difference is purely preference.  But the user should have
that choice available to them, and a forum doesn't allow it.  However,
a mailing list can be linked to a forum-like interface, as in gmane,
and present a searchable archive, as GNU Mailman does.

> Granted, the email system still works somewhat, but modern BB
> systems work so much better

I'm still not convinced the email system was broken in the first
place.

> and they have undeniably useful features that email-based systems
> don't have.

Name them.

-Tim

-- 
---------------------------------------------------------

        Tim Fenn
        [EMAIL PROTECTED]
        Stanford University, School of Medicine
        James H. Clark Center
        318 Campus Drive, Room E300
        Stanford, CA  94305-5432
        Phone:  (650) 736-1714
        FAX:  (650) 736-1961

---------------------------------------------------------

Reply via email to