The fact that you have a 10% split between R/Rfree means your solution is heavily model biased (rule of thumb is a split of <5%). An Rfree of 0.55 would imply randomness. So unfortunately in this case, I dont think that you have an actual solution. You could try MR with a poly-A form of the homology model to see if you get a better phaser solution. Then proceed with the refinement while being careful to keep the R/Rfree within 5% and slowly build in the residues of the rest of your protein based on adequate electron density. Hope this helps.
- Greg ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Greg Costakes, Ph.D. Department of Structural Biology Purdue University Hockmeyer Hall, Room 320 240 S. Martin Jischke Drive, West Lafayette, IN 47907 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ----- Original Message ----- From: "Zhihong Yu" <nkyuz...@gmail.com> To: CCP4BB@JISCMAIL.AC.UK Sent: Thursday, November 7, 2013 11:36:51 AM Subject: [ccp4bb] few questions about resolving new structure through MR Hi, all I'm a rookie in resolving a brand new structure. I have some questions for my current case and look forward to some suggestions. Now I’m working on a protein like this: N-ter(55aa)—domainA(110aa)—linker(30aa)—domainB(150aa)—C-ter(20aa), I got a diffraction data just to 3.5Å, and there is no complete homology structure in pdb bank, but only a homology structure (named as structureX later) for domainB with ~30% sequence identity, so I have some questions as following: 1. Is it possible to find a resolution through MR approach using structureX as a search model? Especially considering that the resolution is only 3.5Å. Currently I just tried once using phaser and refine the structure, I can get a R/Rfree of 0.45/0.55, and it looks like most of backbone in the structureX, especially those within helix or sheet, can be well described by 2Fo-Fc density. Is this primary result promising or not? 2. If it’s possible, what’s the general optimal procedure I should follow? Really thanks for any advice and suggestions! Zhihong