>
> I can find some, if you REALLY want them

No, I get the idea now - its matter of interpretation of  being "in
danger" - your country has a much more stringent defnition of it (which
sounds reasonable to me).  I would assume if someone was REALLY attacking
me, and I was physically in danger of being killed, that i wouldn't be
sentenced to jail if in self defense I killed that other person.  I think
this is reasonable and fair and just.


> You can only judge by what you see, since you CAN'T know what a person
> thinks or feels, and from what I saw of the bombings, they were quite
> willing to bomb villages to get to the terrorists


> > Please cite examples - I disagree completely, I think the US
> > government tried their best NOT to kill citizens and that one
> > of the reasons for the delay in military action against
> > afghanistan was to allow citizens time to get the heck out of
> > cities.
>
> But what if they didn't? Did they check that every city was 100% clear
> of innocents before bombing it? No.

How would the US accomplish this?

> Those who could not travel were left to fend for themselves while bombs
> were falling around them...

Yes.  Sadly, this is true.

>
> > Now, do we agree that the defnition of genocide is to attempt
> > to obliterate (deliberately) a race, culture or group of people?
> > If so would you like to explain what makes you believe that the
> > american government has tried to genocide the afghani people?
> > the notion is quite absurd and quite offensive.  What HITLER did
> > to the jews is attempted genocide.  To compare what the US did to
> > the Afghani people to what hitler did to the jews is really
> > crossing a line.  Do you see the afghani's being sent to work
> > camps? Starved? having thier businesses taken from them?  Do you
> > see them being prevented from going to schools?
>
> My point wasn't a direct comparison, but only to point out that if you
> go "all out" to kill the terrorists (as Kevin started this conversation
> with), then it's only a small step to get to "Kill them before they can
> attack us", which leads to being that way - I wasn't comparing the US
> govt attacks on the Afghan's as similar to the Nazi's, I was only
> pointing out that if you start down that road, you'll end up as a bunch
> of tyrants who kills anyone who they don't like

Fair enough.  I know you weren't comparing the US to Nazi's however I am
pointing out what GENOCIDE really means.  And GENOCIDE is what you have
accused the US of.  Its certainly not fair to call US actions in Afghanistan
genocide, is it?   Has the us really tried to systematically rid the world
of afghanis? No, it hasn't.  Have innocent people been hurt in Afghanistan
by US military action?  Yes, and I believe you have every right to oppose
it, but to call it genocide isnt' really fair.

The other objection I will raise is that Kevin's "kill all terrorist"
thinking is NOT necesarily the thinking of a) the us people or b) the us
government.  In fact, the US attempted to retreive the terrorists through
political means but were thwarted by the Afghani government.


> > I see the US government giving food, money and helping the
> > Afghan people. I see female kids going back to school after
> > their opression.
> >
> > I think the taliban were far more like hitler than the us government.
>
> And after WWII, the Allies gave support to the Germans and Japanese, you
> tend to support the countries you've just bombed the crap out of...
>
> Without that help, the Afghan's would have had NOTHING to live off of,
> since the country-side had been bombed, so nothing was growing on it -
> unless you wanted them to eat rocks, they HAD to have support


Sadly, many of the Afghanis' were eating rocks beforehand.


> > So if I accidentally step on an ant while trying to kill a
> > bee, does this mean I was trying to genocide all ants?
> > Of course not.
>
> No, but if you stomp on an ant colony, destroying their habitat while
> trying to get the bee, then yes, you are commiting genocde of a sort...
> If you see then ant's colony in your way, and you smash through it, then
> you are DEFINITELY trying to kill them...

This ant colony was pretty much decimated by years of wars and opression
already.  This doesnt' justify, nor make acceptable civilians deaths mind
you, but recognize this wasn't a country of healthy, happy free people.  It
was a country where folks lived an opressed life, where folks didnt' have
enough to eat and folks didnt' have freedom.  Now they do.

>
> > And the Afghani people had lots of warning that the US was
> > going to bomb.
> > The Afghani people also knew where the taliban were, mostly.
>
> "Gather all of your possessions, we're about to bomb the crap out of
> your homes, and lively-hood. Have a nice day"
> How generous <g>
>

Sadly, most afghani people had no livelyhood -

> > Sounds like they were trying to kill terrorists.
>
> And it didn't matter if innocents got in the way?


Of course it matters.

Explain to me what the options of the US were, that you think we should have
taken

______________________________________________________________________
Signup for the Fusion Authority news alert and keep up with the latest news in 
ColdFusion and related topics. http://www.fusionauthority.com/signup.cfm

Archives: http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/
Unsubscribe: http://www.houseoffusion.com/index.cfm?sidebar=lists

Reply via email to