> > Sounds less severe than the U.K. indescriminately bombing the civilian
> > population of Germany.  What's your point?
>
> Hang on, in WWII, Germany invaded Poland, France and other countries,
> destroying cities - we bombed them to stop their life-line (and the
> American's didn't believe there was a war for over 2 years) - the Al
> Qadea destroyed one building, crashed into the Pentagon and killed a few
> hundred people - you bomb the crap out of their country... Where's the
> equality?

> I'm not condoning their actions, but the response was one HELL of a step
> up in agression... If you compare the Sept 11/Afghanistan events to
> WWII's bombings, then Germany would have been a huge crater...
>
> > At least now we are making an effort to avoid killing civillians.
>
> So did the UK forces in WWII, they tried to target only cities where
> there were key military installations - since the Germans KNEW they were
> going to get bombed if they stayed in the city (as did the UK
> population), then if they didn't move out, they knew they were taking
> their life into their own hands

So did the Afghans.  It's not like we saddled up and stormed in to
Afghanistan with guns and rockets blazing, laying waste to the entire region
30 minutes after the first plane hit.  We investigated.  We asked
repeatedly.  We warned repeatedly.  They stalled.  We waited.  Finally we
didn't have much of a choice.  What would your preferred response have been?
What would you suggest if a bunch of terrorists flew a plane in to the
palace and a few heavily populated areas and you know they would do it again
as soon as they got another chance?

They blew up embassies and killed hundreds of people.  They attacked one of
our ships killing many sailors.  Finally, they attacked us on our own soil
killing thousands (not hundreds as you said earlier) of civilians.  It
wasn't an isolated thing.  They've been attacking us for a long time and
have shown no signs of stopping.  The last attack, though, was a huge
escalation and one we couldn't ignore.  We were forced to act.

I ask again.  What do you suggest?  Just ignore them and hope they get bored
and give up?

Oh .. and as far as bombing Berlin.  The first time the U.K. bombed was for
revenge for the "accidental" bombing of London.  Don't talk to me about
measured response.  I'm sure the civilians in the first bombing of Berlin
had no idea they were going to be attacked.  How many were killed for the
sake of revenge?

> > I think you are taking a rather extremist position.
>
> Yes, to try and make a point - if you're willing to destroy a country to
> get at a few hundred people, then what are you willing to do if a whole
> country takes arms?

Like I said.  You are exaggerating a bit here.  We hardly destroyed the
country.  Where are you getting all these ideas of mass destruction?

If a whole country takes arms, that's easier.  You have an army to deal with
instead of a bunch of terrorists hiding amongst civilians while plotting to
kill more civilians.

> > If we were that unconcerned about the civilians, I figure a few
> > well placed tactical nukes would have gotten the job done much
> > more quickly and cheaply .. and probably been more effective.  Your
> > accusations are a little rediculus.
>
> Now, nuking gets difficult, as the fall-out would have washed across
> neighboring countries, meaning you'd be "attacking" the neighbors as
> well...

I'm talking about the low yield, low radiation types that are fired from
artillery and such.  You know .. the ones that only take out a few city
blocks.

P.T.

> Philip Arnold

______________________________________________________________________
Structure your ColdFusion code with Fusebox. Get the official book at 
http://www.fusionauthority.com/bkinfo.cfm

Archives: http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/
Unsubscribe: http://www.houseoffusion.com/index.cfm?sidebar=lists

Reply via email to