> If so, then could you drop a note to the developers about why 
> you'd find this advantageous, and why you it disadvantageous to 
> create a local site, please? 

Heh, heh, heh. I don't know your background, John, but this kind of
sounds kind of like the coder vs. designer argument recast. More to the
point, it sounds like the kind of thing developers familiar with Allaire
products feared from the start. I don't mean to pick on Macromedia or
Dreamweaver. You folks do incredible things, but consider the following.

Personally, I think the whole site model is interesting but cumbersome
for much of what I do. Since version 2.5, I've come to use HomeSite to
edit all kinds of files, many of which have nothing to do with Web sites
(mail server SIEVE scripts, batch files, Windows Scripting Host files,
etc.). I've only played with Dreamweaver MX for a couple hours, but it
seemed like the file manager interfaces have been completely eliminated
(or, rather not included).

To open a directory of scripts or edit a non-Web file on one of the
servers, I had to first create a random Web project. Then, I could
navigate to the file through the Desktop tree. However, in addition to
the extra steps it takes to get to a file on a mapped drive, the steps
are somewhat irrelevant. Why should I have to select a Web site project
to edit a SIEVE script on the mail server?

Now, I realize Dreamweaver is built around the Web and that it wasn't
intended to edit non-Web files (nor was HomeSite, I imagine), but this
serves as example of how the Dreamweaver interface forces the developer
into a certain role, one coders might find constraining. Where HomeSite
had a unassuming interface, I found that Dreamweaver MX makes certain
assumptions about my intentions. Consequently, the interface intrudes
into the programming process, getting in the way.

All that said, it isn't really important whether or not Dreamweaver
allows me to do everything I want my editor to do: there are plenty of
mature editing environments out there which I can use in tandem with
Dreamweaver or exclusively if need be. I just bring this up because the
attitude is a little disconcerting: treating something as simple and
fundamental to the HomeSite experience as file browsing as a "feature"
which needs justification just doesn't fly.

Anyway, I'll relent now. :)

Benjamin S. Rogers
http://www.c4.net/
v.508.240.0051
f.508.240.0057

______________________________________________________________________
Your ad could be here. Monies from ads go to support these lists and provide more 
resources for the community. http://www.fusionauthority.com/ads.cfm
FAQ: http://www.thenetprofits.co.uk/coldfusion/faq
Archives: http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/
Unsubscribe: http://www.houseoffusion.com/index.cfm?sidebar=lists

Reply via email to