Diagnostic pragmas are broken because we don't keep track of the diagnostic 
state changes and we only check the current/latest state.
Problems manifest if a diagnostic is emitted for a source line that has 
different diagnostic state than the current state; this can affect
a lot of places, like C++ inline methods, template instantiations, the lexer, 
etc. For example:

struct S {
#pragma clang diagnostic push
#pragma clang diagnostic ignored "-Wtautological-compare"
        void m() { int b = b==b; }
#pragma clang diagnostic pop
};

the pragmas do not work for suppressing the warning in the above case.

The attached patch fixes the issue by having the Diagnostic object keep track 
of the source location of the pragmas so that it is able to know what is the 
diagnostic state at any given source location.

I've also made measurements to see how this fix impacts performance. I 
basically measured how long it takes to do a -fsyntax-only over the llvm/clang 
codebase and the results were:

before the fix: 722.83 sec
after the fix: 727.24 sec

So avoiding the fix only provides a 0.6% gain.

Please review.

-Argiris

Attachment: diag-pragma.diff
Description: Binary data


_______________________________________________
cfe-commits mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.cs.uiuc.edu/mailman/listinfo/cfe-commits

Reply via email to