Refleksi:  Mungkin Ustadz ini hanya mau mengikuti apa yang diwahyukan seperti  
tertulis pada QS 2:223 dimana antara lain dikatakan: "Isteri-isterimu adalah 
(seperti) tanah tempat kamu bercocok-tanam, maka datanglilah tanah tempat 
bercocok tanammu itu bagaimana saja kamu kehendaki...".  Jadi bersalah?

http://www.smh.com.au/news/national/wife-beating-metaphor/2009/01/22/1232471481094.html


Wife beating 'metaphorical': cleric's defender 
Cleric: man can't rape his wife
A Melbourne Islamic cleric has been condemned for preaching that 'a wife must 
respond to her husband for sexual favours' and saying a man can't rape his wife.

January 22, 2009 - 4:57PM

  Statements like (Mr Hamza's) are about as helpful to Islam as a lunatic 
parading himself as an imam
Latest related coverage
What the cleric said on beating wives


  a.. Cleric's rant: Rudd demands apology 
Prime Minister Kevin Rudd and Islamic leaders have condemned a Melbourne Muslim 
cleric who told followers it was permissible to hit their wives and force them 
to have sex.

But Coburg mosque cleric Samir Abu Hamza has told a confidant his message has 
been taken out of context and that he was referring to hitting wives in a 
metaphorical sense.

Mr Rudd told reporters Mr Hamza's comments had no place in modern Australia.

During a 2003 lecture also posted on the internet late last year, Mr Hamza told 
followers that under Islamic law, men could demand sex from their wives.

Despite Australian law requiring consent, it was impossible for a man to rape 
his wife even if she refused to have sex, he said.

"Under no circumstances is sexual violence permissible or acceptable in 
Australia - under no circumstances," Mr Rudd said.

"Under no circumstances are other forms of violence, physical violence, 
acceptable towards women in Australia nor are they acceptable in my view to 
mainstream Muslim teachings.

"Australia will not tolerate these sort of remarks. They don't belong in modern 
Australia, and he should stand up, repudiate them and apologise."

The President of the Islamic Council of Victoria (ICV) Ramzi Elsayed said he 
had spoken with Mr Hamza about the lecture, titled The Keys to a Successful 
Marriage.

"He told me he was speaking in a metaphorical sense," Mr Elsayed said.

"In regards to hitting your wife, his position is that it has always been 
metaphorical - it's not a whack, it's not a slap, it's a wake-up call."

He said Islam did not condone violence against women or making a wife have sex 
with her husband against her will.

"He believes he was taken out of context insofar as he was talking about people 
who censure their spouses - it was not so much a physical hit as a metaphorical 
one to say wake up, we're heading for a divorce kind-of-thing," Mr Elsayed said.

But the senior honorary legal adviser to the Australian Federation of Islamic 
Councils, Haset Seli, hit out at Mr Hamza, calling him a lunatic.

"His lecture was absolutely ludicrous, unIslamic and highlighted the ignorance 
of the man," Mr Seli said.

He said anyone who thinks he can force his wife to have sex with him is a 
lunatic and certainly not a Muslim.

Mr Seli said he went through a similar episode with the former Mufti, Sheik Taj 
Aldin Alhilali, who caused a national uproar in a 2006 Ramadan speech when he 
likened scantily clad women to uncovered meat, suggesting they were to blame 
for sexual attacks on them.

He also claimed at the time that his comments had been taken out of context.

"Statements like (Mr Hamza's) are about as helpful to Islam as a lunatic 
parading himself as an imam," Mr Seli said.

The Federation of Ethnic Communities Councils of Australia (FECCA) said 
violence against women in any form was unacceptable.

"There can be no cultural or religious defence for violence against women," 
said acting FECCA chair Beryl Mulder.

At the Islamic Information and Service Network of Australasia, which Mr Hamza 
runs in Melbourne, a staff member said the comments had been taken "absolutely 
out of context".

"We do not hit our women, you can ask any Muslim woman and she will tell you 
that, it's not part of Islam," the male staff member, who did not want to be 
named, said.

Mr Hamza was on holiday somewhere in Melbourne for the next "couple of weeks," 
the man said.

Sherene Hassan, vice president of the ICV, said she was organising workshops 
for Victorian imams on the issue of domestic violence.

"There may be individuals who have interpreted this lecture as condoning 
violence against women - it's not the first time we have had this problem," she 
said.

She said imams will meet next week to plan workshops to find ways of 
discouraging domestic violence among their followers.

Kirim email ke