http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/11/02/AR2009110202900.html?wpisrc=newsletter&wpisrc=newsletter
Russia's search for an identity
By Masha Lipman
Tuesday, November 3, 2009
MOSCOW
On Friday, as Russia recognized its annual commemoration of political
prisoners, President Dmitry Medvedev published a videoblog in which he
condemned Joseph Stalin's crimes and called on the nation not to forget about
past political repression or its victims. Medvedev called Stalin's repression
"one of the greatest tragedies in Russian history" and expressed concern that
"even today it can be heard that these mass victims were justified by certain
higher goals of the state." He said that "no development of a country, none of
its successes or ambitions can be reached at the price of human losses and
grief." His statement, which led the state-controlled television news, was
sharply at odds with official rhetoric of the past decade.
Medvedev's address may have sounded radical, but many here are skeptical that
the president's words will actually bring change. The number of alarming
signals of Stalin's rehabilitation is growing. And in general over the year and
a half of his presidency, Medvedev's often well-intended rhetoric has not been
matched with policy.
But it would be wrong to dismiss the speech and conclude instead -- as
observers at home and abroad sometimes do -- that Russia has made a definitive
turn "back" toward the Soviet Union and an admiration of Stalin. In fact,
perceptions of Stalin are conflicted, and this conflict reflects Russia's
attempts -- very feeble, so far -- to reinvent itself as a modern nation.
On the one hand, there is evidence of a warming in attitudes toward Stalin. In
one recent example a stanza from the old Soviet anthem was returned to the
Kurskaya metro station in Moscow. Those lines "Stalin raised us, he inspired us
to loyalty to the people, to the labor and heroic deeds" had been removed in
the 1950s as part of Nikita Khrushchev's de-Stalinization campaign; they were
brought back this fall when the station's original decor was restored. Another
instance is the prosecution, on a far-fetched pretext of privacy violation, of
a provincial historian conducting archival research of the fates of ethnic
Germans deported and killed on Stalin's orders. In December, Stalin came in
third in a TV station's poll of greatest Russian historical figures. Contest
organizers are rumored to have tinkered with the results after discovering that
the man who masterminded the extermination of millions of his compatriots
actually finished first.
Yet the peak of Stalin's terror is also recognized for what it was. In 2007, 72
percent of respondents told the Levada polling agency that the repression of
1937-38 were "political crimes that can't be justified." The day of remembrance
of political repression, officially introduced in 1991, is not marked by major
national events, but on Thursday, just outside the infamous Lubyanka building,
the KGB's headquarters and prison, the names of Stalin's victims were read for
12 straight hours by any who wanted to participate. Other commemorations were
staged elsewhere in Russia.
Prime Minister Vladimir Putin recently met with the widow of Alexander
Solzhenitsyn, and they discussed how best to teach his work "The Gulag
Archipelago" in schools. Two years ago, Putin visited a site of mass executions
in the 1930s. The Gulag volumes are available in bookstores, as are a broad
range of works about the history of Communist terror and books that take a much
more positive view of Stalin. Likewise on television, praise of Stalin and his
henchmen appears side by side with series and programs based on works by
Solzhenitsyn and other chroniclers of Stalin's repression.
The perception of Stalin and his crimes has much more to do with the nature of
Russian statehood than with the monstrous actions of the man himself. Russians
cling to the image of Stalin as the embodiment of the great state, and he is
particularly inseparable from the triumph of the Soviet Union over Nazi
Germany. The implication is that individuals may have been cowed, and that the
ferocious state treated them mercilessly, but the state was the vehicle that
inspired Russia's victory in world War II, its greatest achievement of the 20th
century. Ruling elites today are no longer ferocious; rather, they are seen as
greedy and self-serving, but the model of the omnipotent state and the impotent
people is still generally accepted.
For the government, this acceptance of Stalin and the paternalistic
state-society pattern may be handy as a way to consolidate power. But some in
the decision-making circles do seem to realize that current social, political
and economic models are unable to produce growth and development. From Putin
and Medvedev down, modernization has become the mantra. But modernization is
incompatible with a statehood based on the specter of Stalin and faith in the
magic empowerment of the apathetic people by forces of the state. Unless Russia
reinvents itself and takes real steps to encourage people's entrepreneurship
and creativity, talk of modernization will remain hollow.
Medvedev's speech points in the right direction, but it must be accompanied by
changes in policy to carry weight. Moreover, for change to succeed, the
president will need to build a constituency that will trust him, share his
objectives and work toward their implementation. As long as there is no such
constituency in sight, Stalin's name engraved in marble in the Moscow metro
will outweigh Medvedev's humane words.
Masha Lipman, editor of the Carnegie Moscow Center's Pro et Contra journal,
writes a monthly column for The Post.