I use Premiere Pro 2.0 and have used it since Version 1.0. Very steep learning curve and Adobe updates it only once a year no mater how many bugs are in it. 2.0 is somewhat better as it talks to most adobe products. Its bigest failing is producing a DVD that will play on a common DVD player. The codec's used are either not well suited for this or the intention is this is high end DVD stuff and not intended for the amature home jock like me. The codecs are also real sensitive to media. I have a 8X burner and use the best media I can get. 4G of DVD ususally wont play complete on home $100 players. Seems that players cant buffer the stream speed on outer tracks and codec does not take this into account. What I have been doing is to export in ISO then burning from a burner software that seems to do well. I also lower the burn speed to 1x which greatly
helps. Don't realy know why but suspect it has greater burn power for each bit recorded.
I hope someday Cinelerra will fill the problems of PPRo.
Jerry
--- On Wed 08/16, Valentina Messeri < [EMAIL PROTECTED] > wrote:
From: Valentina Messeri [mailto: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To: [email protected]
Date: Wed, 16 Aug 2006 19:07:44 +0200
Subject: Re: [CinCVS] Cinelerra vs Adobe Premiere
>
> Is there in this Community people that use Cinelerra for producing
> movies to be seen in Theatre as a job?
hopefully, some day.....afaic producing movie is not only a question
of software....
>
> Is Adobe Premiere a very expensive perfectly working software, easy to
> learn, with clear instructions manual? Is it an excellent product made
> using a lot of money and
resouces?
anything premiere is, i'm not really interessed, neither was in the past....
>
> Is Cinelerra a worse functioning software (because made by volunteers)
> preferable because free open source software with community support?
;)
next question???
>
> Are the advantages of Cinelerra over Adobe Premiere "social-economical-
> ideological" or also technical?
really dunno.....i make video with linux or make linux with video,
maybe.....can't see any advantage using propietary software, but i can
understand profesionals, they have to produce video...so they use what
is less difficult, and it means win/mac operative system
;)
(benvenuta in paradiso)
ciao
Vale
>
> Grazie
>
> Raffaella
>
>
>
>> Is Cinelerra really a professional software? Do you use it for high
>> quality movies?
>
> This
question is somewhat difficult to answer. If you mean with
> »professional« == "I paid a huge amount of mony and now I just have
> to press the red button and automagically everything settles down, so I
> can catch the tightest deadline" then -- cinelerra pobably is not
> professional software ;-)
> I am using it with the goal to produce high quality material. If you
> know to avoid some possible glitches and pitfalls and -- morover --
> figure out how to get things working as you expect, then cinelerra can
> deliver all the quality you want
>
>> I think I'm scared.... :-)
>
> I can tell you: I felt much more scared all the time I used Premiere;
> there, I always had the feeling to be at the mercy of some big anonymous
> entity and as if my being able to do what I inted and invent really
> doesn't count...
>
>> Did anyone ever compared Cinelerra to Adobe Premiere
Pro?
>
> Guess such comparision would be a very uneven comparison, PPro being
> fostered by one of the bigest graphics/media companies, sold to a
> comparatively high price level -- think at all the resources they can
> throw in...
> Rather, the intersting question is: why are people not just
> shouting and running away form cinelerra? The answer is:
> it actually /is/ working for them, it helps us getting
> done what we can imagine. You can tell this from looking at
> this community: you see new names pop up, people asking the
> first, shy newbee questions. Then you see the same people asking
> more and more advanced questions, some of which you yourself
> couldn't even imagine of, and at some point you see the same
> people helping others knowledgeably...
>
> Hermann V.
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
_______________________________________________
> Cinelerra mailing list
> [email protected]
> https://init.linpro.no/mailman/skolelinux.no/listinfo/cinelerra
>
encosianima.net
----------------------------------------------------------------
This message was sent using IMP, the Internet Messaging Program.
_______________________________________________
Cinelerra mailing list
[email protected]
https://init.linpro.no/mailman/skolelinux.no/listinfo/cinelerra
|
Join Excite! - http://www.excite.com
The most personalized portal on the Web!
- Re: [CinCVS] Cinelerra vs Adobe Premiere [EMAIL PROTECTED]
-
