On Tue, 29 Apr 2025 09:45:37 GMT, Pabulaner IV <d...@openjdk.org> wrote:
> As far as I tested it without the fix only one of the following two things > works: the native menu bar or the open url handler. When you say "native menu bar" I presume you mean the JavaFX SystemMenuBar feature, right? > Because if JFX is installed first, the native menu bar works, but since AWT > is then running embedded, the url handler doesn't work. If JDK / AWT is > installed first the open url handler works, but not the native menu bar, > since JFX is then running embedded. This is what I expected, and answers question 1: the OpenURIHandler feature doesn't work when JavaFX is initialized first and AWT is running embedded. > My fix works for the first issue, as it lets JFX send the OpenURL event to > AWT and therefore fixes it. This doesn't answer question 2, which was _how_ this fixes the problem. As I said above: "In the case where AWT is running embedded, the `[ApplicationDelegate init]` receiver never gets called." So the code you moved / added in `ApplicationDelegate::init` shouldn't ever be executed in the case you are trying to make work. So I don't understand how this PR, which is the AWT portion of the fix, can possibly make any difference in the failing case. That's why I provided the debug patch and asked if you could do a test run, adding the log output as a comment or attachment. ------------- PR Comment: https://git.openjdk.org/jdk/pull/24379#issuecomment-2840131193
