I would second the prudence of taking advantage of wheels already invented if 
you can.  

One thing  I missed, though, in the earlier parts of this thread was  why you 
wanted to use Dewey, Tom?   

Depending on the nature of the items in the collection, you may be better off 
going  with LC   classification.  There could be  more readily available 
complete copy bearing LC numbers and no Dewey numbers.       Going LC  would 
avoid any potential need to later manually tweak the Dewey numbers you get from 
LC   (a possibility you mentioned) - or the complete disruption should a new 
edition of Dewey revise substantially your area...     



Jonathan LeBreton
Senior Associate University Librarian
Editor:  Library & Archival Security
Temple University Libraries
Paley M138,  1210 Polett Walk, Philadelphia PA 19122
voice: 215.204.8231
fax: 215.204.5201
mobile: 215.284.5070
email:  [email protected]
email:  [email protected]


-----Original Message-----
From: Code for Libraries [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Joe 
Hourcle
Sent: Monday, August 11, 2014 10:27 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [CODE4LIB] Dewey code

On Aug 8, 2014, at 10:13 PM, Riley Childs wrote:

> Ok, so you want to access LC data to get Dewey decimal numbers? You need to 
> use a z39.50 client to pull the record, you can do it with marc edit but it 
> is labor intensive.  You would need to roll your own solution for this or use 
> classify.oclc.org to get book info (this doesn't give you API access). Your 
> best bet is classify.oclc.org.
> 
> That aside:
> Honestly you might be better off running with something like Koha, writing a 
> home brew library system is no cake walk, trust me I know from 2 years of 
> experience trying to code one and ultimately moving to koha. Koha can be run 
> on a VPS (Digital Ocean is what i would use) or on an old PC in the corner. I 
> am in a situation similar to yours if you want to contact me off list I can 
> give you some advice.


I 100% agree -- you'd be better off going with something intended for personal 
libraries (eg Delicious Library) and give it a dedicated machine before trying 
to roll your own.

oss4lib hasn't been updated in a while, but Lyrasis is maintaining foss4lib.org 
as a catalog of free & open source library software, and has a 'ILS feature 
comparison tool' which lists feature differences between Koha and Evergreen:

        http://ils.foss4lib.org/

-Joe

Reply via email to