Disclaimer: This is my personal experience and does not reflect the views of, 
nor represent an endorsement by, my employer.

We use Jira in Special Collections to manage all of our tasks, including 
reference requests, web development, and collection processing. Our 
digitization unit also uses it to  manage their workflows. For reference 
requests, we just use a simple contact form, which you can see here: 
https://specialcollections.nal.usda.gov/contact-us
That prevents researchers from having to learn how to use an issue tracker.
(please excuse our very ancient Drupal website)

We do of course also get a lot of requests (reference and otherwise) directly 
emailed to us. For those, we forward them to Jira and CC the person that should 
be assigned the task. We're only using a single project for everything right 
now, but if you have more than one, you can differentiate this by using a 
single gmail account and adding +sometag to the username portion address. I 
didn't interact with Atlassian during the 7-day demo, but they've always been 
quick to respond to problems and questions now that we're using it for real.

We've also been able to use Jira to automate parts of our monthly reports that 
we used to track manually, like items cataloged, time spent on/collections used 
for reference requests, and collections maintenance tasks. Using Ruby and the 
Jira API, I can pull all of that into an Excel spreadsheet or TSV file (I'm 
hoping to share the code for this soon).

The major downsides of Jira are the complexity and price. And I don't recommend 
self-hosting or you'll add a lot of administrative burden.

Before settling on Jira, we also evaluated both Redmine (which had previously 
been used by our IT department) and EasyRedmine. I don't think vanilla Redmine 
is terribly user friendly, but I liked EasyRedmine a lot. In the end it just 
wasn't quite customizable enough for  us, though. If you don't need to do a lot 
of customization, I'd definitely recommend it (personally). The staff were also 
helpful/engaging during the 14-day demo period.

Our helpdesk uses RT, but it's suuuuuper barebones, at least from what I can 
see.

For general note-keeping and organizing of procedures (including how to use 
Jira :), we use a shared OneNote notebook. This is partly because I'm a 
OneNote-pusher and partly because it's already part of the standard workstation 
image.

Best,
Rachel


Date:    Wed, 11 May 2016 07:48:23 +0000
From:    Ben Companjen <ben.compan...@dans.knaw.nl>
Subject: Re: Back-of-house software

Hi Stuart,

First thought (or what should have been my first thought): what problem(s) are 
you trying to solve?
I sometime wish I had software that is better geared for service management 
(including incident management, CRM and documentation), but in our small 
organisation with three main services it has already been helpful to structure 
the information differently and get it together in well-known places. For the 
Dataverse service that I'm managing we use Google Drive/Docs, ownCloud and JIRA.

Incident and service request management is the most important process/business 
function that I think would benefit from software support. Emails, tasks and 
notes in various places aren't enough anymore to keep track of problems and 
questions. JIRA helps a little, but not all requests relate to software 
problems and I don't want to use it for every simple-to-answer question.

Have you asked your institution's IT service desk for suggestions? They might 
be able to support when you choose the same software. Our IT uses RT and seems 
happy with it. I'm hoping to get a queue for Dataverse-related requests in 
their system.

Hope this helps.

Ben





This electronic message contains information generated by the USDA solely for 
the intended recipients. Any unauthorized interception of this message or the 
use or disclosure of the information it contains may violate the law and 
subject the violator to civil or criminal penalties. If you believe you have 
received this message in error, please notify the sender and delete the email 
immediately.

Reply via email to