ferruzzi commented on code in PR #43340:
URL: https://github.com/apache/airflow/pull/43340#discussion_r1821177852


##########
tests/core/test_otel_logger.py:
##########
@@ -358,108 +358,134 @@ def test_timer_start_and_stop_manually_send_true(self, 
mock_time, metrics_consis
         )
 
     def test_incr_counter(self):
-        # Arrange
-        logger = self.stats
         metric_name = "test_metric"
         count = 5
         tags = {"env": "prod"}
 
-        # Act
-        logger.incr(metric_name, count=count, tags=tags)
+        self.stats.incr(metric_name, count=count, tags=tags)
 
-        # Assert
-        counter = logger.metrics_map.get_counter(
-            full_name(prefix=logger.prefix, name=metric_name), attributes=tags
+        counter = self.stats.metrics_map.get_counter(
+            full_name(prefix=self.stats.prefix, name=metric_name), 
attributes=tags
         )
         counter.add.assert_called_with(count, attributes=tags)
 
     def test_decr_counter(self):
-        # Arrange
-        logger = self.stats
         metric_name = "test_metric"
         count = 3
         tags = {"env": "prod"}
 
-        # Act
-        logger.decr(metric_name, count=count, tags=tags)
+        self.stats.decr(metric_name, count=count, tags=tags)
 
-        # Assert
-        counter = logger.metrics_map.get_counter(
-            full_name(prefix=logger.prefix, name=metric_name), attributes=tags
+        counter = self.stats.metrics_map.get_counter(
+            full_name(prefix=self.stats.prefix, name=metric_name), 
attributes=tags
         )
         counter.add.assert_called_with(-count, attributes=tags)
 
     @pytest.mark.parametrize("expected_duration", [2.5, 1.0, 3.0])
     def test_timing(self, expected_duration):
-        # Arrange
-        logger = self.stats
         metric_name = "test_metric"
         tags = {"env": "prod"}
 
         # Mocking time.perf_counter to simulate timing
         with mock.patch.object(time, "perf_counter", side_effect=[0.0, 
expected_duration]):
-            with logger.timer(metric_name, tags=tags) as timer:
+            with self.stats.timer(metric_name, tags=tags) as timer:
                 pass
 
-        # Assert
+        acceptable_margin = 0.1
         assert isinstance(timer.duration, float)
-        assert timer.duration >= expected_duration - 0.1
-        assert timer.duration <= expected_duration + 0.1
+        assert timer.duration >= expected_duration - acceptable_margin
+        assert timer.duration <= expected_duration + acceptable_margin
         assert self.meter.get_meter().create_observable_gauge.call_count == 1
         self.meter.get_meter().create_observable_gauge.assert_called_once_with(
-            name=full_name(prefix=logger.prefix, name=metric_name), 
callbacks=ANY
+            name=full_name(prefix=self.stats.prefix, name=metric_name), 
callbacks=ANY
         )
 
     def test_gauge_set(self):
-        # Arrange
-        logger = self.stats
         metric_name = "test_metric"
         value = 42
         tags = {"env": "prod"}
 
-        # Act
-        logger.gauge(metric_name, value, tags=tags)
+        self.stats.gauge(metric_name, value, tags=tags)
 
-        # Assert
-        current_value = 
logger.metrics_map.poke_gauge(full_name(prefix=logger.prefix, 
name=metric_name), tags)
+        current_value = self.stats.metrics_map.poke_gauge(
+            full_name(prefix=self.stats.prefix, name=metric_name), tags
+        )
         assert current_value == value
 
     def test_gauge_increment(self):
-        # Arrange
-        logger = self.stats
         metric_name = "test_metric"
         count = 10
         tags = {"env": "prod"}
 
-        # Act
-        logger.gauge(metric_name, count, delta=True, tags=tags)  # Use 
delta=True to increment the gauge
+        self.stats.gauge(metric_name, count, delta=True, tags=tags)  # Use 
delta=True to increment the gauge
 
-        # Assert
         # Retrieve the current value using poke_gauge
-        current_value = 
logger.metrics_map.poke_gauge(full_name(prefix=logger.prefix, 
name=metric_name), tags)
+        current_value = self.stats.metrics_map.poke_gauge(
+            full_name(prefix=self.stats.prefix, name=metric_name), tags
+        )
         assert current_value == count
 
     def test_gauge_decrement(self):
-        # Arrange
-        logger = self.stats
         metric_name = "test_metric"
         count = 5
         tags = {"env": "prod"}
 
-        # Act: Increment the gauge by 'count'
-        logger.gauge(metric_name, count, delta=True, tags=tags)
+        self.stats.gauge(metric_name, count, delta=True, tags=tags)
 
-        # Assert: Check if the current value after incrementing is equal to 
'count'
-        current_value_after_increment = logger.metrics_map.poke_gauge(
-            full_name(prefix=logger.prefix, name=metric_name), tags
+        current_value_after_increment = self.stats.metrics_map.poke_gauge(
+            full_name(prefix=self.stats.prefix, name=metric_name), tags
         )
         assert current_value_after_increment == count  # Ensure the gauge 
value reflects the increment
 
-        # Act for decrement
-        logger.gauge(metric_name, -count, delta=True, tags=tags)  # Decrement 
the gauge by 'count'
+        self.stats.gauge(metric_name, -count, delta=True, tags=tags)  # 
Decrement the gauge by 'count'
 
-        # Assert: Ensure the gauge value reflects the decrement to zero
-        current_value_after_decrement = logger.metrics_map.poke_gauge(
-            full_name(prefix=logger.prefix, name=metric_name), tags
+        current_value_after_decrement = self.stats.metrics_map.poke_gauge(
+            full_name(prefix=self.stats.prefix, name=metric_name), tags
         )
         assert current_value_after_decrement == 0
+

Review Comment:
   Nitpick, non-blocking: Consider combining the following test cases into one 
parameterized test which accepts `(test_name, test_tags, expected_message)`,  
For an example of what that could look like, check out [this 
test](https://github.com/apache/airflow/blob/main/providers/tests/amazon/aws/operators/test_appflow.py#L212)



-- 
This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service.
To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the
URL above to go to the specific comment.

To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]

For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at:
[email protected]

Reply via email to