commits  

Messages by Date

• 2026/08/29 Re: [PR] test: fix smoke test failures on xen/vmware [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/29 Re: [PR] test: fix smoke test failures on xen/vmware [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/29 (cloudstack) branch main updated (6764ca5ea3f -> 77fbb0f0333) dahn
• 2026/08/29 Re: [PR] github: skip Copilot reviews for draft PRs [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/29 Re: [PR] test: fix smoke test failures on xen/vmware [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] enable Reproducible Builds [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] test: fix smoke test failures on xen/vmware [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] enable Reproducible Builds [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] test: fix smoke test failures on xen/vmware [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] test: fix smoke test failures on xen/vmware [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] VMware to KVM: cold (VDDK) and warm (CBT) migration into Ceph/RBD and Linstor, plus importVm adoption of existing RBD root volumes and Linstor root/data volumes [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] VMware to KVM: cold (VDDK) and warm (CBT) migration into Ceph/RBD and Linstor, plus importVm adoption of existing RBD root volumes and Linstor root/data volumes [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [I] Allow Host to be put in Maintenance Mode while Up and Disabled [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [I] Display Tags in the UI for each ACL Rule, and allow users to filter [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack) branch dependabot/maven/framework/db/org.mariadb.jdbc-mariadb-java-client-3.3.5 created (now 0716508a6c2) github-bot
• 2026/08/28 [PR] build(deps): bump org.mariadb.jdbc:mariadb-java-client from 3.1.4 to 3.3.5 in /framework/db [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [I] Ubuntu 26.04 Support [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] realtime re-balance remote agents [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack) 01/03: Store last successful MS host for agent reconnection fallback pearl11594
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] Network Extension: Orchestrate external Network devices [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] NAS backup: compression, encryption, bandwidth throttle, integrity check [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] Add option to control MAC address reuse for VR public NICs [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] Store last successful MS host for agent reconnection fallback [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] Indirect agent connection improvements [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 [I] [SHORT FUNCTIONAL DESCRIPTION] [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] Introduce new backup provider (KBOSS) [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack) branch store-lastsuccessful-MS updated (ab30cf815cd -> 3ee96084884) pearl11594
• 2026/08/28 Re: [I] [aw] Detection Runs [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [I] [FEATURE] WireGuard as a VPN option on the Virtual Router [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] Redact sensitive duplicate query parameter values in ApiServlet logs [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] Store last successful MS host for agent reconnection fallback [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] new tenant instead of add account [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [I] [UI] "Add Account" form misleads users into creating unintended multi‑account tenants instead of adding users [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack) branch store-lastsuccessful-MS updated (3ee96084884 -> d42e2aaef08) pearl11594
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] Store last successful MS host for agent reconnection fallback [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] Redact sensitive duplicate query parameter values in ApiServlet logs [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] Store last successful MS host for agent reconnection fallback [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] CLVM enhancements and fixes [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] Network Extension: Orchestrate external Network devices [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack) 03/03: Potential fix for pull request finding pearl11594
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] Redact sensitive duplicate query parameter values in ApiServlet logs [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack) 02/03: Addressed code review comments pearl11594
• 2026/08/28 [PR] Store last successful MS host for agent reconnection fallback [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack) branch store-lastsuccessful-MS created (now ab30cf815cd) pearl11594
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.20 Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.20 Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.23/main Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] Fix id in listguestosmapping search [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] Update bouncy castle [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.23/main Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] NAS backup: compression, encryption, bandwidth throttle, integrity check [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] NAS backup: automated infrastructure backup (database, configs, certificates) [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] NAS backup: compression, encryption, bandwidth throttle, integrity check [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] marvin: use pycryptodome instead of PyCrypt [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] nasbackup: fix backup stopped vm on Ubuntu 26.04 [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] guard against stopping stats background threads [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack-terraform-provider) 01/01: Fix role_permission reorder collision and authoritative drift detection manojkumar
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack-terraform-provider) branch fix/role-permission-reorder-drift created (now e1f2374) manojkumar
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] new tenant instead of add account [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack-terraform-provider) 02/03: Document ForceNew-field footgun after cloudstack_service_offering import manojkumar
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack-terraform-provider) 03/03: Add snake_case display_text field to cloudstack_project, deprecate displaytext manojkumar
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack-terraform-provider) branch fix/storage-range-import-project-displaytext created (now 992f58e) manojkumar
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack-terraform-provider) 01/03: Mark storage_network_ip_range netmask/start_ip/end_ip as ForceNew manojkumar
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack) branch ghi9640-agent-lb-indirect-svm created (now 0b0f83cbd87) dahn
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] realtime re-balance remote agents [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] realtime re-balance remote agents [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] realtime re-balance remote agents [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] realtime re-balance remote agents [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] realtime re-balance remote agents [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 [PR] realtime re-balance remote agents [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack) 01/01: realtime re-balance remote agents dahn
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack-terraform-provider) 01/01: Fix cloudstack_ipaddress delete silently succeeding on source-NAT IPs manojkumar
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack-terraform-provider) branch fix-ipaddress-sourcenat-delete created (now 98695a5) manojkumar
• 2026/08/28 Re: [I] Session key is not cleared when SAML Global Log Out API is called [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack-terraform-provider) 01/01: Fix internet_protocol/routing_mode case mismatch causing perpetual replace on cloudstack_vpc_offering manojkumar
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack-terraform-provider) branch fix/vpc-offering-case-insensitive-forcenew-fields created (now cf16eda) manojkumar
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] Linstor 4.22 shared storagepool support [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] load balance individual hosts when clusters are to big to distribute [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] backport: usage: widen usage_volume unique key to include vm_id (#13909) [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 [PR] load balance individual hosts when clusters are to big to distribute [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack) 01/01: load balance individual hosts when clusters are to big to distribute dahn
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack) branch ghi9640-agent-lb-partial-cluster created (now b11258f1374) dahn
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] test: fix smoke test failures on xen/vmware [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] backport: Incremental NAS backup support for KVM (#13074) [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] test: fix smoke test failures on xen/vmware [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] test: fix smoke test failures on xen/vmware [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [I] Session key is not cleared when SAML Global Log Out API is called [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 [PR] fix: clear session cookies on SAML SLO logout to prevent stale session key [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] test: fix smoke test failures on xen/vmware [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] test: fix smoke test failures on xen/vmware [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] test: fix smoke test failures on xen/vmware [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.20 Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack-terraform-provider) 01/01: Fix private gateway ACL update using wrong SDK setter manojkumar
• 2026/08/28 (cloudstack-terraform-provider) branch fix/private-gateway-acl-update created (now c6dab7b) manojkumar
• 2026/08/28 Re: [I] Ubuntu 26.04 Support [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] linstor: grow cloned volumes inside the clone to fix resize race with BalanceAfterClone [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 [PR] linstor: grow cloned volumes inside the clone to fix resize race with BalanceAfterClone [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] build(deps): bump the github-actions-dependencies group across 1 directory with 9 updates [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 [I] Session key is not cleared when SAML Global Log Out API is called [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.20 Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.20 Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.23/main Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/28 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.22 Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] optimise prometheus scraping workflow [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 (cloudstack) branch dependabot/github_actions/github-actions-dependencies-47168f74c8 updated (ba9f0b95eee -> 6da89cb04de) github-bot
• 2026/08/27 Re: [I] agent attache rebalancing doesn't work in MSses [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] github: skip Copilot reviews for draft PRs [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] github: skip Copilot reviews for draft PRs [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 [PR] github: skip Copilot reviews for draft PRs [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] feature: instance boot group and readiness rules [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.23/main Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] VMware to KVM: cold (VDDK) and warm (CBT) migration into Ceph/RBD and Linstor, plus importVm adoption of existing RBD root volumes and Linstor root/data volumes [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 (cloudstack) branch healthcheck-4.20 updated (a062b5a5a80 -> 63fd982f49f) dahn
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.16/main Health Check please don't merge this [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.19 Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 (cloudstack) branch healthcheck-main updated (89052fd1f5f -> 1afe9a54c92) dahn
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 21/main Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] Health Check PR: 4.15 [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] Default branch 'main' (renamed from 'master') Health Checks - Please don't merge this [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.20 Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.22 Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.23/main Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] backport: Incremental NAS backup support for KVM (#13074) [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH][4.13] Health Check Run [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.20 Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.16 Health Check please don't merge this [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.23/main Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.23/main Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.20/main Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.21/main Health Check, please don't merge this [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.22 Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [DO NOT MERGE] Health Check Master: Dummy commit [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.19/main Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.18/main Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.23/main Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] usage: widen usage_volume unique key to include vm_id [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] allow MS to start when DB version is behind by a NoOp upgrade step [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [I] [UI] "Add Account" form misleads users into creating unintended multi‑account tenants instead of adding users [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH][master/4.14] Health Check Run [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH][4.14] Health Check Run [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.15 Health Check please don't merge this [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.20 Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 [PR] build(deps): bump pacote and npm-check-updates in /ui [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 (cloudstack) branch dependabot/npm_and_yarn/ui/multi-0fe65ac183 created (now 415e21e90a4) github-bot
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [4.9] Smoketest health checkrun [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] Revert `registerUserKeys` back to a synchronous API [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] oauth: api: add missing version since [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 (cloudstack) branch dis13919-upgradeDbNoop deleted (was ba363db5371) dahn
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] Fix type parameter in listBackupServiceJobs API [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] 4.13.0.0/master: health checks smoketests [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH][master/4.14] Health Check Run [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [4.11] Smoketest Health Check [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.20 Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.19 LTS Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.18 LTS Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.20/main Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.18 LTS Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.23/main Health Check, please don't merge this [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.20 Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.23/main Health Check, please don't merge this [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.17 Health Check please don't merge this [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.16 Health Checks - Please don't merge [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH][4.15] Health Check Run [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.23/main Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.22 Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] feature: instance boot group and readiness rules [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.22 Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 (cloudstack) branch healthcheck-4.22 updated (d9f3381112e -> 93321e4aaab) dahn
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.22 Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.23/main Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] Add missing project cleanups while deleting/moving user [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] Add NULL check during restoreVM operation when host is removed [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] Exclude Apache CXF dependency from kvm hypervisor plugin [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [I] [UI] "Add Account" form misleads users into creating unintended multi‑account tenants instead of adding users [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] feature: instance boot group and readiness rules [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] feature: instance boot group and readiness rules [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] feature: instance boot group and readiness rules [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] feature: instance boot group and readiness rules [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [I] [UI] "Add Account" form misleads users into creating unintended multi‑account tenants instead of adding users [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] backport: Incremental NAS backup support for KVM (#13074) [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.23/main Health Check, please don't merge this [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [HEALTH] 4.22 Health Check, please don't merge this! [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [WIP] Add opt-in Usage Reporter (call-home) for the CloudStack project [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [I] Ubuntu 26.04 support [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] optimise prometheus scraping workflow [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [I] Ubuntu 26.04 support [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 [I] Ubuntu 26.04 Support [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 [I] Ubuntu 26.04 support [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] backport: Incremental NAS backup support for KVM (#13074) [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] VMware to KVM: cold (VDDK) and warm (CBT) migration into Ceph/RBD and Linstor, plus importVm adoption of existing RBD root volumes and Linstor root/data volumes [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] backport: Incremental NAS backup support for KVM (#13074) [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] backport: Incremental NAS backup support for KVM (#13074) [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] test: read and set nas.backup.incremental.enabled for the test zone [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [I] application vm are crashing in a cluster with mixed CPU model hardware [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] [WIP] Add opt-in Usage Reporter (call-home) for the CloudStack project [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] make vlan check conditional on management network for xen [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] fix: use auth_client_required instead of removed auth_supported for RBD [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] backport: Incremental NAS backup support for KVM (#13074) [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] backport: Incremental NAS backup support for KVM (#13074) [cloudstack] via GitHub
• 2026/08/27 Re: [PR] test: read and set nas.backup.incremental.enabled for the test zone [cloudstack] via GitHub

• Earlier messages
• Later messages