xiangfu0 commented on code in PR #19795: URL: https://github.com/apache/pinot/pull/19795#discussion_r4254175269
########## pinot-segment-local/src/main/java/org/apache/pinot/segment/local/customobject/tdigest/TDigestCodec.java: ########## @@ -0,0 +1,865 @@ +/** + * Licensed to the Apache Software Foundation (ASF) under one + * or more contributor license agreements. See the NOTICE file + * distributed with this work for additional information + * regarding copyright ownership. The ASF licenses this file + * to you under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the + * "License"); you may not use this file except in compliance + * with the License. You may obtain a copy of the License at + * + * http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0 + * + * Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, + * software distributed under the License is distributed on an + * "AS IS" BASIS, WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY + * KIND, either express or implied. See the License for the + * specific language governing permissions and limitations + * under the License. + */ +package org.apache.pinot.segment.local.customobject.tdigest; + +import java.lang.invoke.MethodHandles; +import java.lang.invoke.VarHandle; +import java.nio.BufferUnderflowException; +import java.nio.ByteBuffer; +import java.nio.ByteOrder; +import java.util.Arrays; + +/// Reads and writes the legacy t-digest 3.2/3.3 formats, validating lengths before allocating centroid arrays. +/// Fresh output respects both readers' capacities without narrowing doubles. Historical fractional endpoints and +/// opaque corrupted payloads retain their original limitations; byte preservation does not ensure reverse upgrades. +/// Endpoint repair, capacity fallback and point-mass interpolation can change quantiles on historical data. +/// This utility has no shared mutable state; callers must exclusively own input buffers and parser state. +public final class TDigestCodec { + public static final int VERBOSE_ENCODING = 1; + public static final int SMALL_ENCODING = 2; + private static final int LEGACY_CAPACITY_PADDING = 10; + public static final int VERBOSE_HEADER_SIZE = 32; + public static final int VERBOSE_CENTROID_SIZE = 16; + public static final int SMALL_HEADER_SIZE = 30; + public static final int SMALL_CENTROID_SIZE = 8; + public static final int DEFAULT_MERGE_BUFFER_MULTIPLIER = 5; + + private TDigestCodec() { + } + + /// Reads the compression from a validated header without decoding centroid arrays. + public static double readCompression(byte[] bytes) { + return readSerializedHeader(ByteBuffer.wrap(bytes)).compression(); + } + + /// Rejects non-finite compression while retaining the legacy clamping of finite settings below ten. + public static void validateCompression(double compression) { + if (!Double.isFinite(compression)) { + throw new IllegalArgumentException("Invalid TDigest compression: " + compression); + } + } + + /// Applies the legacy minimum compression to query, ingestion and serialized-header settings. + public static double normalizeCompression(double compression) { + validateCompression(compression); + return Math.max(compression, 10.0); + } + + /// Writes validated centroid arrays in the standard verbose encoding without sorting or recompression. + /// The caller retains the arrays; only the first `count` entries are written, with normalized compression. + public static byte[] serializeCentroids(double compression, double min, double max, double[] means, + double[] weights, int count) { + if (count < 0 || count > means.length || count > weights.length) { + throw new IllegalArgumentException("Invalid TDigest centroid count: " + count); + } + ByteBuffer encoded = ByteBuffer.allocate(Math.addExact(VERBOSE_HEADER_SIZE, + Math.multiplyExact(VERBOSE_CENTROID_SIZE, count))); + encoded.putInt(VERBOSE_ENCODING).putDouble(min).putDouble(max).putDouble(normalizeCompression(compression)); + encoded.putInt(count); + for (int i = 0; i < count; i++) { + encoded.putDouble(weights[i]).putDouble(means[i]); + } + return encoded.array(); + } + + /// Encodes validated, sorted native centroids and selects a legacy-compatible representation. + static byte[] serializeCompatibleCentroids(double compression, double min, double max, double[] means, + double[] weights, int count, boolean inheritedFractionalBoundaries) { + if (count < 0 || count > 0 && (count > means.length || count > weights.length || !(min <= max))) { + throw new IllegalArgumentException("Invalid TDigest centroid count or extrema"); + } + ByteBuffer buffer = ByteBuffer.allocate( Review Comment: Addressed in 21d26f9798. Keeping this separate for the scoped migration. The raw writer is used by historical recovery/reduction and malformed-input fixtures, while the native writer validates fresh centroids and collects compatibility metadata during the write. Folding them behind a flag would mix those contracts or add another centroid pass. The layout constants are shared; this refactor is optional and no format change is needed here. ########## pinot-segment-local/src/main/java/org/apache/pinot/segment/local/customobject/tdigest/TDigestCodec.java: ########## @@ -0,0 +1,865 @@ +/** + * Licensed to the Apache Software Foundation (ASF) under one + * or more contributor license agreements. See the NOTICE file + * distributed with this work for additional information + * regarding copyright ownership. The ASF licenses this file + * to you under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the + * "License"); you may not use this file except in compliance + * with the License. You may obtain a copy of the License at + * + * http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0 + * + * Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, + * software distributed under the License is distributed on an + * "AS IS" BASIS, WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY + * KIND, either express or implied. See the License for the + * specific language governing permissions and limitations + * under the License. + */ +package org.apache.pinot.segment.local.customobject.tdigest; + +import java.lang.invoke.MethodHandles; +import java.lang.invoke.VarHandle; +import java.nio.BufferUnderflowException; +import java.nio.ByteBuffer; +import java.nio.ByteOrder; +import java.util.Arrays; + +/// Reads and writes the legacy t-digest 3.2/3.3 formats, validating lengths before allocating centroid arrays. +/// Fresh output respects both readers' capacities without narrowing doubles. Historical fractional endpoints and +/// opaque corrupted payloads retain their original limitations; byte preservation does not ensure reverse upgrades. +/// Endpoint repair, capacity fallback and point-mass interpolation can change quantiles on historical data. +/// This utility has no shared mutable state; callers must exclusively own input buffers and parser state. +public final class TDigestCodec { + public static final int VERBOSE_ENCODING = 1; + public static final int SMALL_ENCODING = 2; + private static final int LEGACY_CAPACITY_PADDING = 10; + public static final int VERBOSE_HEADER_SIZE = 32; + public static final int VERBOSE_CENTROID_SIZE = 16; + public static final int SMALL_HEADER_SIZE = 30; + public static final int SMALL_CENTROID_SIZE = 8; + public static final int DEFAULT_MERGE_BUFFER_MULTIPLIER = 5; + + private TDigestCodec() { + } + + /// Reads the compression from a validated header without decoding centroid arrays. + public static double readCompression(byte[] bytes) { + return readSerializedHeader(ByteBuffer.wrap(bytes)).compression(); + } + + /// Rejects non-finite compression while retaining the legacy clamping of finite settings below ten. + public static void validateCompression(double compression) { + if (!Double.isFinite(compression)) { + throw new IllegalArgumentException("Invalid TDigest compression: " + compression); + } + } + + /// Applies the legacy minimum compression to query, ingestion and serialized-header settings. + public static double normalizeCompression(double compression) { + validateCompression(compression); + return Math.max(compression, 10.0); + } + + /// Writes validated centroid arrays in the standard verbose encoding without sorting or recompression. + /// The caller retains the arrays; only the first `count` entries are written, with normalized compression. + public static byte[] serializeCentroids(double compression, double min, double max, double[] means, + double[] weights, int count) { + if (count < 0 || count > means.length || count > weights.length) { + throw new IllegalArgumentException("Invalid TDigest centroid count: " + count); + } + ByteBuffer encoded = ByteBuffer.allocate(Math.addExact(VERBOSE_HEADER_SIZE, + Math.multiplyExact(VERBOSE_CENTROID_SIZE, count))); + encoded.putInt(VERBOSE_ENCODING).putDouble(min).putDouble(max).putDouble(normalizeCompression(compression)); + encoded.putInt(count); + for (int i = 0; i < count; i++) { + encoded.putDouble(weights[i]).putDouble(means[i]); + } + return encoded.array(); + } + + /// Encodes validated, sorted native centroids and selects a legacy-compatible representation. + static byte[] serializeCompatibleCentroids(double compression, double min, double max, double[] means, + double[] weights, int count, boolean inheritedFractionalBoundaries) { + if (count < 0 || count > 0 && (count > means.length || count > weights.length || !(min <= max))) { + throw new IllegalArgumentException("Invalid TDigest centroid count or extrema"); + } + ByteBuffer buffer = ByteBuffer.allocate( + Math.addExact(VERBOSE_HEADER_SIZE, + Math.multiplyExact(VERBOSE_CENTROID_SIZE, count))); + buffer.putInt(VERBOSE_ENCODING); + buffer.putDouble(min); + buffer.putDouble(max); + buffer.putDouble(compression); + buffer.putInt(count); + double encodedWeight = 0.0; + boolean hasNonFiniteMeans = false; + boolean fractionalWeights = false; + for (int i = 0; i < count; i++) { + if (!(weights[i] > 0.0) || !Double.isFinite(weights[i]) || !(means[i] >= min && means[i] <= max)) { + throw new IllegalArgumentException("Invalid TDigest centroid"); + } + buffer.putDouble(weights[i]); + buffer.putDouble(means[i]); + encodedWeight += weights[i]; + hasNonFiniteMeans |= !Double.isFinite(means[i]); + fractionalWeights |= weights[i] != Math.rint(weights[i]); + } + if (!Double.isFinite(encodedWeight)) { + throw new IllegalArgumentException("TDigest total weight exceeds the supported range"); + } + boolean weightedBoundaries = count == 1 ? weights[0] >= 2.0 + : count > 1 && (weights[0] > 1.0 || weights[count - 1] > 1.0); + // Collect exact wire metadata during the write rather than decoding and validating our fresh bytes again. + SerializedTDigestMetadata metadata = new SerializedTDigestMetadata(VERBOSE_ENCODING, min, max, + compression, count, + VERBOSE_HEADER_SIZE, VERBOSE_CENTROID_SIZE, buffer.capacity(), encodedWeight, + hasNonFiniteMeans, false, false, fractionalWeights, weightedBoundaries, false, compression, Double.NaN, + Double.NaN, Double.NaN); + return makeLegacyCompatible(buffer.array(), metadata, inheritedFractionalBoundaries); + } + + /// Rejects fresh boundary masses that legacy readers cannot recompress without inventing mass. + /// Call after boundary normalization and removing zero-weight centroids; fractional interior mass is supported. + static void checkLegacyBoundaryWeights(int count, double firstWeight, double lastWeight) { + if (count > 0 && (firstWeight < 1.0 || lastWeight < 1.0 + || count == 1 && firstWeight != 1.0 && firstWeight < 2.0)) { + throw new IllegalArgumentException("Cannot serialize fractional TDigest boundary mass for legacy readers: " + + "check add(value, weight) inputs; firstWeight=" + firstWeight + ", lastWeight=" + lastWeight + + "; unit endpoints are required, while fractional interior mass remains supported"); + } + } + + /// Allows unsupported endpoints only at exact means inherited from validated legacy bytes. A tolerance could + /// grant the exception to fresh extrema. Fresh fractional input at or beyond an endpoint permanently excludes it, + /// even if its historical mass was merged away or the new weight equals the historical weight. + static boolean hasInheritedFractionalBoundaryEncoding(TDigest source, int count, double firstMean, + double firstWeight, double lastMean, double lastWeight) { + if (count <= 0 || !source.hasValidStatistics() || !(firstWeight > 0.0) || !(lastWeight > 0.0) + || !Double.isFinite(firstWeight) || !Double.isFinite(lastWeight)) { + return false; + } + boolean singleton = count == 1 && firstWeight != 1.0 && firstWeight < 2.0; + boolean firstUnsupported = firstWeight < 1.0 || singleton; + boolean lastUnsupported = lastWeight < 1.0 || singleton; + return (firstUnsupported || lastUnsupported) + && (!firstUnsupported || firstMean == source.getHistoricalFractionalBoundaryMean(true) + && !(source.getFreshFractionalBoundaryMean(true) <= firstMean)) + && (!lastUnsupported || lastMean == source.getHistoricalFractionalBoundaryMean(false) + && !(source.getFreshFractionalBoundaryMean(false) >= lastMean)); + } + + private static void checkSerializedBoundaryWeights(byte[] bytes, SerializedTDigestMetadata metadata) { + int count = metadata.centroidCount(); + if (count > 0) { + ByteBuffer encoded = ByteBuffer.wrap(bytes); + int firstOffset = metadata.centroidOffset(); + int lastOffset = firstOffset + (count - 1) * metadata.centroidSize(); + double firstWeight = metadata.encoding() == VERBOSE_ENCODING + ? encoded.getDouble(firstOffset) : encoded.getFloat(firstOffset); + double lastWeight = metadata.encoding() == VERBOSE_ENCODING + ? encoded.getDouble(lastOffset) : encoded.getFloat(lastOffset); + checkLegacyBoundaryWeights(count, firstWeight, lastWeight); + } + } + + /// Converts a verbose `MergingDigest` payload to a representation readable by t-digest 3.2 and 3.3. + /// + /// The input must use the standard verbose `MergingDigest` encoding. The returned payload stays verbose when it + /// already fits both legacy default capacities, uses compact encoding only when every narrowed field is exact, and + /// otherwise reduces interior centroids without narrowing doubles. Compression below ten is normalized in the + /// output header because the 3.2 verbose reader sizes its arrays from the raw header before applying that minimum. + /// Opaque degraded state is retained without reducing its unknown distribution, including over-capacity payloads. + /// Fresh fractional endpoints that legacy unit-boundary repair cannot represent are rejected without reweighting. + public static byte[] makeLegacyCompatible(byte[] verboseBytes) { + return makeLegacyCompatible(verboseBytes, inspectSerialized(ByteBuffer.wrap(verboseBytes), false)); + } + + /// Uses metadata validated for these exact retained bytes, avoiding another centroid validation walk. + public static byte[] makeLegacyCompatible(byte[] verboseBytes, SerializedTDigestMetadata metadata) { + return makeLegacyCompatible(verboseBytes, metadata, false); + } + + /// Retains exact verbose weights for inherited historical fractional endpoints that cannot become unit endpoints. + /// All other compatibility checks apply. These payloads keep their historical assertion-enabled 3.3 read/merge + /// limitation; callers must establish inherited endpoint provenance before enabling this exception. + static byte[] makeLegacyCompatible(byte[] verboseBytes, SerializedTDigestMetadata metadata, + boolean inheritedFractionalBoundaries) { + if (metadata.encoding() != VERBOSE_ENCODING) { + throw new IllegalArgumentException("Expected verbose TDigest encoding"); + } + if (metadata.needsLegacyFallback()) { + return verboseBytes; + } + if (!Double.isNaN(metadata.recoveredInfinityMean())) { + double[] means = new double[metadata.centroidCount()]; + double[] weights = new double[means.length]; + decodeSerializedCentroids(ByteBuffer.wrap(verboseBytes), metadata, means, weights); + if (!inheritedFractionalBoundaries) { + return serializeRecoveredCentroids(metadata, means, weights); + } + verboseBytes = serializeCentroids(metadata.compression(), metadata.min(), metadata.max(), means, weights, + means.length); + metadata = inspectSerialized(ByteBuffer.wrap(verboseBytes), false); + } + if (metadata.hasZeroWeightCentroids()) { + verboseBytes = removeZeroWeightCentroids(verboseBytes, metadata); + metadata = inspectSerialized(ByteBuffer.wrap(verboseBytes), false); + } + if (!inheritedFractionalBoundaries) { + checkSerializedBoundaryWeights(verboseBytes, metadata); + } + double compression = metadata.compression(); + if (metadata.encodedCompression() != compression) { + verboseBytes = verboseBytes.clone(); + ByteBuffer.wrap(verboseBytes).putDouble(20, compression); + } + int centroidCount = metadata.centroidCount(); + int legacyCapacity = + Math.min(getLegacyDefaultCentroidCapacity(compression), getDefaultCentroidCapacity(compression)); + if (centroidCount <= legacyCapacity) { + return verboseBytes; + } + int mainCapacity = getDefaultCentroidCapacity(compression); + long bufferCapacity = DEFAULT_MERGE_BUFFER_MULTIPLIER * (long) mainCapacity; + if (centroidCount > mainCapacity || inheritedFractionalBoundaries || (double) (float) compression != compression + || centroidCount > Short.MAX_VALUE + || mainCapacity > Short.MAX_VALUE || bufferCapacity > Short.MAX_VALUE) { + return reduceVerboseCentroids(verboseBytes, legacyCapacity); + } + ByteBuffer verbose = ByteBuffer.wrap(verboseBytes); + ByteBuffer centroids = verbose.duplicate(); + centroids.position(metadata.centroidOffset()); + for (int i = 0; i < centroidCount; i++) { + double weight = centroids.getDouble(); + double mean = centroids.getDouble(); + if ((double) (float) weight != weight || (double) (float) mean != mean) { + return reduceVerboseCentroids(verboseBytes, legacyCapacity); + } + } + + ByteBuffer small = ByteBuffer.allocate(SMALL_HEADER_SIZE + SMALL_CENTROID_SIZE * centroidCount); + verbose.rewind(); + verbose.getInt(); + small.putInt(SMALL_ENCODING); + small.putDouble(verbose.getDouble()); + small.putDouble(verbose.getDouble()); + verbose.getDouble(); + verbose.getInt(); + small.putFloat((float) compression); + small.putShort((short) mainCapacity); + small.putShort((short) bufferCapacity); + small.putShort((short) centroidCount); + for (int i = 0; i < centroidCount; i++) { + small.putFloat((float) verbose.getDouble()); + small.putFloat((float) verbose.getDouble()); + } + return small.array(); + } + + private static byte[] serializeRecoveredCentroids(SerializedTDigestMetadata metadata, double[] means, + double[] weights) { + TDigestAccumulator digest = TDigestAccumulator.forLegacyAggregation(metadata.compression()); + digest.addHistoricalCentroids(means, weights, means.length, metadata.min(), metadata.max(), true); + digest.inheritHistoricalFractionalBoundaries(metadata.historicalFractionalMinMean(), + metadata.historicalFractionalMaxMean()); + return digest.serialize(); + } + + private static byte[] removeZeroWeightCentroids(byte[] verboseBytes, SerializedTDigestMetadata metadata) { + ByteBuffer source = ByteBuffer.wrap(verboseBytes); + source.position(metadata.centroidOffset()); + ByteBuffer filtered = ByteBuffer.allocate(metadata.encodedLength()); + filtered.put(verboseBytes, 0, VERBOSE_HEADER_SIZE); + int count = 0; + for (int i = 0; i < metadata.centroidCount(); i++) { + double weight = source.getDouble(); + double mean = source.getDouble(); + if (weight != 0.0) { + filtered.putDouble(weight).putDouble(mean); + count++; + } + } + filtered.putInt(28, count); + return Arrays.copyOf(filtered.array(), filtered.position()); + } + + /// Validates serialized lengths and centroid values without allocating centroid arrays. + public static double validateSerialized(byte[] bytes) { + return validateSerialized(ByteBuffer.wrap(bytes)); + } + + /// Validates one legacy digest without changing `input` and returns its total centroid weight. + /// + /// Trailing bytes remain available to the caller for intermediate values containing several objects. + public static double validateSerialized(ByteBuffer input) { + return validateSerialized(input, true); + } + + private static double validateSerialized(ByteBuffer input, boolean checkCapacity) { + return inspectSerialized(input, checkCapacity).totalWeight(); + } + + /// Header and numerical metadata for one legacy byte payload. The centroid bytes remain owned by the caller. + /// Header-only inspection leaves total weight as NaN until centroid inspection validates the numerical fields. + /// + /// Legacy writers can emit poisoned numerical state after overflow or broken fractional boundary repair. + /// Such state is retained with degraded quantiles, rather than being passed to the sorted K1 kernel. + public record SerializedTDigestMetadata(int encoding, double min, double max, double compression, + int centroidCount, int centroidOffset, int centroidSize, + int encodedLength, double totalWeight, boolean hasNonFiniteMeans, boolean needsLegacyFallback, + boolean unorderedMeans, boolean fractionalWeights, boolean weightedBoundaries, boolean hasZeroWeightCentroids, + double encodedCompression, double recoveredInfinityMean, double historicalFractionalMinMean, + double historicalFractionalMaxMean) { + /// Whether the encoded centroid view can be used unchanged by healthy pending-state readers and writers. + public boolean isCanonicalPayload() { + return !needsLegacyFallback && !weightedBoundaries && !unorderedMeans && !hasZeroWeightCentroids + && Double.isNaN(recoveredInfinityMean); + } + } + + /// Invocation-local parser state. Primitive byte-array reads avoid per-row buffer and metadata allocations. + /// Public metadata and retained pending payloads receive immutable snapshots instead of sharing this state. + static final class SerializedTDigestState { + private static final VarHandle SHORT_VIEW = + MethodHandles.byteArrayViewVarHandle(short[].class, ByteOrder.BIG_ENDIAN); + private static final VarHandle INT_VIEW = MethodHandles.byteArrayViewVarHandle(int[].class, ByteOrder.BIG_ENDIAN); + private static final VarHandle LONG_VIEW = MethodHandles.byteArrayViewVarHandle(long[].class, ByteOrder.BIG_ENDIAN); + + int _encoding; + double _min; + double _max; + double _compression; + int _centroidCount; + int _centroidOffset; + int _centroidSize; + int _encodedLength; + double _totalWeight; + boolean _hasNonFiniteMeans; + boolean _needsLegacyFallback; + boolean _unorderedMeans; + boolean _fractionalWeights; + boolean _weightedBoundaries; + boolean _hasZeroWeightCentroids; + double _encodedCompression; + double _recoveredInfinityMean; + double _historicalFractionalMinMean; + double _historicalFractionalMaxMean; + private byte[] _bytes; + private ByteBuffer _buffer; + private int _position; + private int _limit; + + void reset(byte[] bytes) { + _bytes = bytes; + _buffer = null; + _position = 0; + _limit = bytes.length; + } + + void reset(ByteBuffer input) { + _bytes = null; + _buffer = input.slice().order(ByteOrder.BIG_ENDIAN); + _position = 0; + _limit = _buffer.limit(); + } + + void copyFrom(SerializedTDigestMetadata metadata) { + _encoding = metadata.encoding(); + _min = metadata.min(); + _max = metadata.max(); + _compression = metadata.compression(); + _centroidCount = metadata.centroidCount(); + _centroidOffset = metadata.centroidOffset(); + _centroidSize = metadata.centroidSize(); + _encodedLength = metadata.encodedLength(); + _totalWeight = metadata.totalWeight(); + _hasNonFiniteMeans = metadata.hasNonFiniteMeans(); + _needsLegacyFallback = metadata.needsLegacyFallback(); + _unorderedMeans = metadata.unorderedMeans(); + _fractionalWeights = metadata.fractionalWeights(); + _weightedBoundaries = metadata.weightedBoundaries(); + _hasZeroWeightCentroids = metadata.hasZeroWeightCentroids(); + _encodedCompression = metadata.encodedCompression(); + _recoveredInfinityMean = metadata.recoveredInfinityMean(); + _historicalFractionalMinMean = metadata.historicalFractionalMinMean(); + _historicalFractionalMaxMean = metadata.historicalFractionalMaxMean(); + } + + SerializedTDigestMetadata snapshot() { + return new SerializedTDigestMetadata(_encoding, _min, _max, _compression, _centroidCount, _centroidOffset, + _centroidSize, _encodedLength, _totalWeight, _hasNonFiniteMeans, _needsLegacyFallback, _unorderedMeans, + _fractionalWeights, _weightedBoundaries, _hasZeroWeightCentroids, _encodedCompression, _recoveredInfinityMean, + _historicalFractionalMinMean, _historicalFractionalMaxMean); + } + + double weight(int index) { + _position = _centroidOffset + index * _centroidSize; + return _centroidSize == VERBOSE_CENTROID_SIZE ? readDouble() : readFloat(); + } + + double mean(int index) { + _position = _centroidOffset + index * _centroidSize + _centroidSize / 2; + double mean = _centroidSize == VERBOSE_CENTROID_SIZE ? readDouble() : readFloat(); + return Double.isNaN(mean) ? _recoveredInfinityMean : Math.max(_min, Math.min(mean, _max)); Review Comment: Addressed in 21d26f9798. These sites enforce different invariants: decoded-value restoration after validation, exact unit-endpoint mass repair, bounded first-moment roundoff, and arithmetic interpolation/merge range safety. The normalization entry points already share normalizeBoundaries. Combining them into one clamp policy risks silently accepting a payload whose repair must fail. I am leaving the broader refactor out to keep this migration scoped. -- This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service. To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the URL above to go to the specific comment. To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at: [email protected] --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]
