You must test with Gnu-Go level 16.. This is according to Stefan Mertin by
far the best mode. But it takes sometimes quite a long time till Gnu-Go
makes it move.
In your experiments Gun-Go played very fast. You played fast Blitz and
Gnu-Go had a big time handicap (besides Handtalk, which plays Ultra-Blitz).
Chrilly
----- Original Message -----
From: "Hiroshi Yamashita" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: "computer-go" <computer-go@computer-go.org>
Sent: Wednesday, January 10, 2007 6:10 PM
Subject: [computer-go] Gnugo vs commercial programs
I tested Gnugo against some commercial programs.
Gnugo is 3.7.10.
Level is default with --never-resign and --komi 6.5 option.
Commercial program is max level.
All game is Japanese rule and komi is 6.5.
gnugo wins losses winning rate average score
GinseiIgo5 (KCC Igo ) 11 55 0.17 -31.3 points
Saikouhou3 (Haruka ) 13 44 0.23 -41.4 points
TuyoiIgo4 (Go4++ ) 27 54 0.33 -11.4 points
ShudanTaikyoku3 (Handtalk) 29 37 0.44 - 4.5 points
GinseiIgo5 ... KCC Igo, published in 2004.
Saikouhou3 ... Haruka, published in 2002. Latest version.
TuyoiIgo4 ... Go4++, published in 2003. Engine is 2002 version.
ShudanTaikyoku3 ... Handtalk, published in 1999.
These are not latest version except Haruka.
All game records are here.
http://www.yss-aya.com/gnugo_vs_result.zip
Average expended hours.
KCC 17m51s Gnugo 3m14s, Opteron248(2.2GHz)
Haruka 11m53s Gnugo 4m28s, Opteron248(2.2GHz) + AthlonXP 2100+(1.73GHz)
Go4++ 4m59s Gnugo 2m18s, Opteron248(2.2GHz)
Handtalk 2m42s Gnugo 5m22s, AthlonXP 2100+(1.73GHz)
Appendix.
GnuGo 3.5.4 (January, 2004 version) test result. Level is default.
gnugo wins losses winning rate average score
ValueIgo3 (KCC Igo ) 4 26 0.13 -36.6 points
TuyoiIgo4 (Go4++ ) 11 19 0.37 -6.5 points
ShudanTaikyoku3 (Handtalk ) 12 18 0.40 -3.8 points
AI Igo2004 (ManyFaces) 18 12 0.60 +11.7 points
ValueIgo3 ... KCC Igo, published in 2003. same GinseiIgo2PW(2001?)
AI Igo2004 ... ManyFaces, published in 2003. engine is 2003?
-------------------------------------------
Regards,
Hiroshi Yamashita
_______________________________________________
computer-go mailing list
computer-go@computer-go.org
http://www.computer-go.org/mailman/listinfo/computer-go/
_______________________________________________
computer-go mailing list
computer-go@computer-go.org
http://www.computer-go.org/mailman/listinfo/computer-go/
