On Sun, Apr 07, 2002 at 03:02:53PM -0700, Justin Christopher wrote:
> Windows 2000, RedHat, Mac OS X, and Mac OS 9 clients
> can retrieve IPs from my Apple Airport Basestation on
> both wired and wireless interfaces. Mandrake PPC
> cannot. To me, that means that there is a problem with
> Mandrake, not with the Base Station. If other
> operating systems have managed to connect to it, so
> should Mandrake. Attempting to blame the problem on
> "Apple's software bugs and hardware failures" is a
> lame cop-out. There's nothing wrong with my
> basestation. 

No it's not a lame copout.  The DHCP clients work for everyone *BUT*
you (I'd say Airport users but I don't recall anyone else having this
issue).  These are the same daemons that x86 uses.  So if
there's a problem with them it would have been discovered by now.  So
that tells me Apple isn't following the standard in some way.

> The "internet connections to start at boot" problem
> only occurs if getting IPs fails 9 or 10 lines higher
> in the boot process. If you successfully get IPs you
> will not see this problem. I'll be happy to get out
> the digital camera if it will help you believe that
> this problem exists. 

I believe that you're having the problem.  I always setup my ethernet
interface and my airport interface.  Both fail the first time since:
a) I don't plug in my ethernet interface at home, but I leave it turned
on at boot.
b) My airport (as you've already complained about) doesn't have the
ESSID and the key set, so it can't get an address.

Despite both of these interfaces failing to get a DHCP address I'm still
unable to replicate your problem.  So there is something more to this
than just those two interfaces failing.

> I'm not even going to elaborate on Gnome. It, and it's
> various components crash all the time and you know it.
> Others on this list have the same problem. Use it for
> 5 minutes and something will crash, guaranteed. 

No I don't know it.  If you can't elaborate it can't be fixed.

> If Stew needs his own Airport stuff to make Airport
> work, then perhaps his EMPLOYER should buy it for him.
> I already offered to buy 1/10th of the Airport
> equipment for Stew, and if I recall, there was 1 other taker.

Please read the explanation of what the PPC port is to Mandrake that was
given by the CEO in response to a thread I started.  It's not a money
making affair.  It's a contribution to the community.  And a rather
large one at that.

As far as your offer to buy him an Airport that's great.  But obviously
it's not a big enough issue for the rest of the users to find 8 more
users to do it.

-- 
Ben Reser <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
http://ben.reser.org

What difference does it make to the dead, the orphans, and the homeless,
whether the mad destruction is wrought under the name of totalitarianism
or the holy name of liberty and democracy? - Ghandi

Reply via email to