Today is about the fourth time I had to explain that pressing "Y" for a 
filesystem check on an uncleanly shutdown system is a bit idea, at least 
on ext3. I think I had it myself once or twice as well. If you do this 
fsck is very likely to remove a bit to many of your files. It actually 
seems much worse than normally on ext2 (but it is a long time ago that I 
used ext2, so perhaps its normal), and it is definately much worse than 
using the journal to restore the fs.

In any case, rc.sysinit message sounds like if pressing Yes within 5 
seconds is a good idea, while on a journalling system, it is probably not 
the best idea. So either:
- remove the message al together for journalling fs (an expert can still 
do it manually, if for some reason it is wanted)
- make the check sound like a bad idea.

d.





Reply via email to