http://qa.mandrakesoft.com/show_bug.cgi?id=5566
------- Additional Comments From [EMAIL PROTECTED] 2003-12-09 18:04 ------- You are reading too much into my comments. I am not saying that the Windows menu system is better, only that applications installed on Windows automatically create a menu item which, for most people, is sufficient! I hope Windows' application installers would correctly use folders within the Windows menus, including Microsoft themselves. However, installers do not rely on non- technical users to be using any menu-editors and the like. Actually, the Mandrake menus are fairly well arranged. Mandrakesoft cannot expect to distribute all appliations in the growing Linux applications base, nor can it expect to support a user of an older Mandrake release who wnats to install a newer application. As the Linux base grows, the number of non-GPL applications will increase and these vendors will need an easy way to work with all the distributions out there. And that includes the menu creation steps. Unfortunately, all Linux distributions want to do things differently. There is no standard install method, no guarantee that a menu item will be created, and sometimes, as in the case of Yahoo Messenger, you have to go search using rpm where the application was installed and what it is called. It is frustrating to install applications under Linux distributions. There still is work to be done so that Linux desktops will appeal to the non- technical public. I once read a comment on a Linux forum which said "if one does not know how to compile a program, one should not be using a computer anyways". That attitude is unaccetable, in my humble opinion. -- Configure bugmail: http://qa.mandrakesoft.com/userprefs.cgi?tab=email ------- You are receiving this mail because: ------- You are on the CC list for the bug, or are watching someone who is. ------- Reminder: ------- assigned_to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] status: RESOLVED creation_date: description: Mandrake has used a menu links location (/usr/share/applnk-mdk) that is different from the default KDE menus (/usr/share/applnk). This is a major issue and could relegate desktop Linux to the wastebasket if not standardized upon. No Linux distribution should expect third party developers to create different versions of their installers to take care of all the distributions out there. The menu location should be standardized and the KDE default location can be used by all Linux distributions. If not, third party software installers will not create links in the KDE "start" menu. I verified this with CodeWarrior 6 and there were no links created in the Mandrake menus. Links were however, correctly created in the default KDE menu path. Installing OpenOffice after downloading from the OpenOffice.org site also does the same. I would strongly suggest using the same location as KDE does for menus. Mandrake can add items and folders to that standard location and build the applnk-mdk menus there.
