Hi Alex,

This looks good.

Hi Sherman, Alan,

Could one of you review this, please

The "-n" options seems okay but I wonder if there has any thought given to having an option on jarsigner to normalize it before signing?

The PM requirement was for jar, in that when a jar is created it should
be ready to go.


On the patch itself then I think it needs to be cleaned up before pushing it. From a quick look:

- It's using a raw type for the packer properties, should be Map<String, String>
- Is any reason not to use try-with-resources?
- I assume the catching of Exception in createTemporaryFile should be IOException|SecurityException
- Is the @test tag in the test right?
- The test appears to extract jfr.jar but I don't think we can assume this exists - Some of the jar tests use sun.tools.jar.Main and this might be useful here One other thing, Mathias's mail to jdk8-dev [1] asks for changes that require translation to be in the master no longer than 10/24. Does the update to jar.properties count?

Yes, it does, as there are properties changes and man page changes.
We will need to special case this somehow.

Kumar


-Alan

[1] http://mail.openjdk.java.net/pipermail/jdk8-dev/2013-October/003443.html

Reply via email to